TYBMS SEM 6: Human Resource: Human Resource Accounting & Audit (Q.P April 2019 with Solution)

Paper/Subject Code: 86016/Human Resource: Human Resource Accounting & Audit 

TYBMS SEM 6: 

Human Resource: 

Human Resource Accounting & Audit 

(Q.P April 2019 with Solution)

Please check whether you have got the right question paper.

1. All questions are compulsory. 

2. Figures to the right indicate marks.

Q.1 A) Multiple Choice Questions (Any 8)                              08

1) The cost to acquire a new employee is called as ____________

a) Acquisition cost 

b) Hiring cost

c) Selection cost

d) Recruitment cost

2) Human resource accounting does an accounting of _________ in the firm.

a) Human assets 

b) Machines

c) Salaries

d) Both a & b

3) Replacement cost is _________ historical cost

a) Expensive than 

b) Cheaper than 

c) Same as

d) Both a & b

4) Opportunity cost is _________ Cost

a) Speculation

b) Scientific

c) Ascertained

d) Tax shield

5) The word audit is derived from Latin word __________

a) audite

b) audire

c) auditet

d) auditler

6) The object of modern audit is to report on _______ position.

a) Market 

b) Social

c) Financial

d) Present

7) ________ is one of the effective principle of auditing.

a) Integrity

b) Unity

c) Togetherness

d) dependency

8) ___________ involves training to newly employed employee in the organization

a) Recruitment 

b) Selection 

c) induction

d) Promotion

9) __________ cost refers to the cost of replacing an existing employee.

a) Opportunity 

b) Replacement

c) Economic

d) Historical

10) The ___________ manual should serve as a guide for the department to maintain human resource services effectively.

a) Policy

b) HR

c) Regulations

d) Work

B) Match the following: (Any 7)                                07

Column A	Column B
1) Third stage	a) 1971-76
2) Fourth stage	b) Speculative loss on unachieved productivity
3) Opportunity cost	c) 1976-80
4) New Hire orientation process	d) Retaining Documents
5) Hiring process	e) Training
6) Briefing & Orientation	f) Limitation to HR audit
7) Performance Management	g) Process of HR audit
8) Unstructured interview	h) Performance related pay
9) Questionnaire method	i) Spontaneity of Questions
10) Lack of management commitment	j) Scientific of objective

 Ans: 

Column A	Column B
1) Third stage	a) 1971-76
2) Fourth stage	c) 1976-80
3) Opportunity cost	b) Speculative loss on unachieved productivity
4) New Hire orientation process	e) Training
5) Hiring process	d) Retaining Documents
6) Briefing & Orientation	g) Process of HR audit
7) Performance Management	h) Performance related pay
8) Unstructured interview	i) Spontaneity of Questions
9) Questionnaire method	j) Scientific of objective
10) Lack of management commitment	f) Limitation to HR audit

 

Q.2 A) What do you mean by HR accounting? Discuss its significance.              08

HR accounting refers to the practice of quantifying and analyzing the financial impact of human resource activities and investments within an organization. It involves measuring, recording, and reporting the costs associated with managing and developing human capital.

The significance of HR accounting lies in its ability to provide organizations with valuable insights and data-driven decision-making in the field of human resources. Here are some key reasons why HR accounting is important:

1. Cost Analysis: HR accounting helps in analyzing the costs associated with various HR activities such as recruitment, training and development, compensation and benefits, employee turnover, and performance management. It allows organizations to identify areas of high expenditure and evaluate the effectiveness and efficiency of HR investments.

2. Budgeting and Resource Allocation: By understanding the costs and returns of HR initiatives, organizations can allocate their resources more effectively. HR accounting helps in setting realistic budgets, determining the optimal allocation of funds, and prioritizing HR investments based on their potential financial impact.

3. ROI Evaluation: HR accounting enables organizations to assess the return on investment (ROI) of their human capital strategies. It helps in quantifying the financial benefits derived from HR activities and determining whether they are generating a positive return. This information is crucial for evaluating the effectiveness of HR programs and making data-driven decisions for future investments.

4. Strategic Decision Making: HR accounting provides HR professionals and organizational leaders with objective data and metrics to support strategic decision-making. It helps in aligning HR strategies with overall business goals, identifying areas for improvement, and making informed choices on talent management, workforce planning, and employee development.

5. Compliance and Reporting: HR accounting assists organizations in meeting legal and regulatory requirements by accurately recording and reporting HR-related financial information. It ensures transparency and accountability in financial reporting, which is essential for stakeholders, shareholders, and external auditors.

6. Benchmarking and Performance Measurement: HR accounting allows organizations to compare their HR costs and performance against industry benchmarks and best practices. It helps in identifying areas of strength and areas that need improvement, enabling organizations to implement strategies for continuous improvement.

HR accounting provides a structured framework to measure and evaluate the financial impact of human capital management. It helps organizations optimize their HR investments, align HR strategies with business objectives, and make informed decisions that drive organizational success.

B) Explain the components of Acquisition cost.                  07

The components of acquisition cost, also known as hiring cost or recruitment cost, refer to the expenses incurred by an organization during the process of recruiting and selecting new employees. These costs can vary depending on the organization's recruitment methods, strategies, and the complexity of the hiring process. The components of acquisition cost include:

1. Advertising and Marketing: This component includes the cost of advertising job openings through various channels such as online job boards, print media, social media, or recruitment agencies. It also includes expenses related to promoting the employer brand and conducting employer branding activities.

2. Recruitment Agency Fees: If an organization utilizes the services of external recruitment agencies to source and screen candidates, there may be fees associated with these services. These fees typically depend on the type of positions being filled and the level of expertise required.

3. Employee Referral Programs: Organizations often encourage their employees to refer potential candidates for open positions. This component includes expenses related to referral bonuses or rewards given to employees who successfully refer candidates who are eventually hired.

4. Background Checks and Screening: Conducting background checks, reference checks, and pre-employment screenings are essential steps in the hiring process. The costs associated with these activities, such as fees paid to background check providers or drug testing facilities, are included in the acquisition cost.

5. Travel and Accommodation: In some cases, organizations may need to incur expenses for travel and accommodation when conducting interviews or assessments for candidates who are located in different regions or countries.

6. Selection Tests and Assessments: The use of aptitude tests, personality assessments, and other selection tools can help evaluate candidates' suitability for a particular role. The costs associated with administering these tests, purchasing assessment tools, or hiring external consultants to conduct assessments are part of the acquisition cost.

7. Interviewing Expenses: This component includes costs related to conducting interviews, such as scheduling interviews, arranging interview rooms, and providing reimbursement for candidates' travel expenses when applicable.

8. Administrative and Processing Costs: These costs cover administrative tasks associated with the recruitment process, such as the time spent by HR personnel in reviewing resumes, conducting initial screenings, and coordinating interview schedules. It may also include expenses related to applicant tracking systems or recruitment software.

9. Onboarding and Orientation: While onboarding expenses are not typically considered part of the acquisition cost, some organizations may include certain onboarding costs in this category. This may include expenses related to new hire orientation, training programs, or providing necessary equipment or resources to new employees.

OR

Q.2 Explain the advantages & disadvantages of HR Accounting.            (15)

1. Improved Decision Making: HR accounting provides organizations with quantifiable data and financial metrics related to human resource activities. This data-driven approach helps in making more informed decisions regarding HR strategies, investments, and resource allocation. It enables organizations to identify the most effective and efficient HR practices and make adjustments where needed.

2. Cost Analysis and Control: HR accounting allows organizations to analyze and control their HR costs. By measuring and monitoring the financial impact of various HR activities, such as recruitment, training, and employee turnover, organizations can identify areas of excessive spending and implement cost-saving measures. It helps in optimizing HR investments and improving cost-efficiency.

3. Evaluation of HR Programs: With HR accounting, organizations can evaluate the effectiveness and ROI of their HR programs and initiatives. It provides a structured approach to assess the financial benefits and outcomes derived from HR activities. This evaluation helps in identifying successful programs that can be continued or expanded and identifying areas for improvement or reallocation of resources.

4. Alignment with Business Goals: HR accounting enables organizations to align their HR strategies and practices with overall business objectives. By quantifying the financial impact of HR activities, organizations can ensure that their human capital management efforts are directly contributing to organizational success. It helps in establishing a clear connection between HR outcomes and business performance.

5. Compliance and Reporting: HR accounting facilitates compliance with legal and regulatory requirements related to financial reporting. It ensures accurate and transparent recording and reporting of HR-related costs, enabling organizations to demonstrate their adherence to accounting standards. This helps in building trust with stakeholders, shareholders, and auditors.

Disadvantages of HR Accounting:

1. Complexity and Implementation Challenges: Implementing HR accounting can be complex and challenging, requiring organizations to establish appropriate systems, processes, and metrics for measuring HR costs and outcomes. It may require significant investment in technology, training, and expertise. Organizations may face resistance from HR professionals who are not accustomed to working with financial metrics.

2. Difficulty in Measuring Intangible Factors: HR accounting primarily focuses on quantifiable financial metrics, which may not capture the full value of human capital. Intangible factors such as employee morale, engagement, and organizational culture are difficult to measure and may not be adequately represented in HR accounting calculations. This limitation may result in an incomplete picture of the value of human resources.

3. Subjectivity and Assumptions: HR accounting involves making certain assumptions and judgments when assigning financial values to HR activities. This introduces subjectivity into the process, and different organizations may have varying approaches and interpretations. Subjectivity can limit the comparability and reliability of HR accounting data.

4. Time and Resource Intensive: Implementing HR accounting practices and maintaining accurate records of HR costs and outcomes can be time-consuming and resource-intensive. It requires ongoing data collection, analysis, and reporting. Small organizations with limited HR and financial resources may find it challenging to implement comprehensive HR accounting systems.

5. Focus on Short-Term Financial Metrics: HR accounting tends to emphasize short-term financial metrics and outcomes, such as cost reduction and ROI, which may overshadow long-term strategic HR goals. This narrow focus on financial outcomes may not fully capture the value of HR activities that have long-term benefits, such as talent development and succession planning.

Q.3 A) Explain opportunity cost & its benefits        (08)

Opportunity cost refers to the potential benefit or value that is forgone when choosing one option over another. It is the cost of the next best alternative that must be sacrificed when making a decision.

Benefits of Understanding and Considering Opportunity Cost:

1. Decision Making: Understanding opportunity cost helps in making better decisions by considering the trade-offs involved. It prompts individuals and organizations to evaluate the potential benefits and drawbacks of different options and choose the one that offers the highest value. By recognizing the opportunity cost, decision-makers can avoid making choices that may result in significant missed opportunities.

2. Resource Allocation: Opportunity cost aids in effective resource allocation. When resources such as time, money, or manpower are limited, it becomes crucial to allocate them optimally. By evaluating the opportunity cost of different uses of resources, organizations can allocate them in a way that maximizes the overall benefits and avoids wasting resources on less valuable alternatives.

3. Evaluating Investments: Opportunity cost is valuable in investment decision-making. When considering investment options, individuals and organizations must compare the potential returns and risks of different investments. Understanding the opportunity cost helps in assessing the relative benefits of each investment and selecting the option that provides the highest potential return on investment.

4. Time Management: Opportunity cost is particularly relevant to time management. Time is a finite resource, and every decision involves allocating time to one activity at the expense of others. By recognizing the opportunity cost of how time is spent, individuals can prioritize tasks and activities that align with their goals and provide the greatest value. It helps in avoiding time wastage on low-value activities and focusing on high-priority tasks.

5. Goal Alignment: Opportunity cost encourages individuals and organizations to align their decisions and actions with their long-term goals and objectives. By considering the potential benefits and sacrifices associated with different options, decision-makers can choose the alternatives that are most closely aligned with their desired outcomes. It facilitates a more strategic and goal-oriented approach to decision-making.

6. Risk Assessment: Opportunity cost helps in assessing the risks associated with different choices. By considering the potential losses or missed opportunities of a particular decision, individuals and organizations can evaluate the risk-reward trade-off. It prompts a more comprehensive analysis of the potential downsides and upsides of each option and assists in making informed risk management decisions.

7. Continuous Improvement: Understanding opportunity cost fosters a mindset of continuous improvement. By regularly evaluating the opportunity cost of decisions and actions, individuals and organizations can identify areas for improvement and innovation. It encourages the exploration of alternative approaches and strategies that may yield higher returns or better outcomes.

B) Explain economic value model. State its disadvantages.         (07)

The economic value model is a framework used to assess the financial value or worth of a particular investment or project. It focuses on the economic benefits and costs associated with the investment and aims to determine whether the potential benefits outweigh the costs.

The economic value model takes into account various factors such as cash flows, discounted cash flow analysis, return on investment (ROI), net present value (NPV), and other financial metrics to evaluate the economic viability of an investment. It helps decision-makers assess the financial impact and potential profitability of a project before making investment decisions.

Disadvantages of the Economic Value Model:

1. Limited Scope: The economic value model primarily focuses on financial metrics and may not consider other important factors such as social, environmental, or intangible impacts of an investment. It may not capture the full range of benefits or costs associated with a project, leading to an incomplete assessment of its value.

2. Subjectivity and Assumptions: Like any financial model, the economic value model requires making assumptions and estimates. These assumptions can introduce subjectivity and uncertainty into the analysis. The model's accuracy and reliability depend on the quality of the assumptions made, and incorrect or biased assumptions can lead to misleading results.

3. Complexity: The economic value model can be complex, especially when dealing with large or long-term projects. It requires gathering and analyzing extensive financial data, discounting future cash flows, and considering various scenarios and assumptions. The complexity of the model can make it challenging for decision-makers without financial expertise to understand and interpret the results accurately.

4. Sensitivity to Input Parameters: The economic value model is sensitive to the input parameters used in the analysis, such as discount rates, growth rates, and cost estimates. Small changes in these parameters can significantly impact the results and conclusions of the model. The sensitivity of the model to input parameters should be carefully considered and sensitivity analyses may be required to assess the robustness of the results.

5. Inability to Predict Future Conditions: The economic value model relies on assumptions and projections of future economic conditions, which are inherently uncertain. Changes in market conditions, economic factors, or industry dynamics can significantly impact the projected financial outcomes. The model may not accurately predict future conditions or account for unexpected events or disruptions.

6. Ignoring Non-Financial Factors: The economic value model focuses primarily on financial factors and may not adequately consider non-financial factors that can influence the success or value of an investment. Factors such as customer satisfaction, employee engagement, brand reputation, or regulatory risks may not be adequately captured in the model, leading to an incomplete assessment of the investment's value.

7. Lack of Flexibility: The economic value model relies on fixed assumptions and calculations, which may limit its flexibility in adapting to changing circumstances or evolving project conditions. It may not provide a dynamic assessment of the investment's value over time or account for adjustments or course corrections that may be needed during the project lifecycle.

OR

Q.3 Explain replacement cost model. State its advantages & limitations. (15)

The replacement cost model is a valuation approach used to estimate the value of an asset by determining the cost of replacing it with a similar or equivalent asset at current market prices. It is commonly used in accounting, insurance, and asset valuation to assess the value of assets based on their replacement or reproduction costs.

Advantages of the Replacement Cost Model:

1. Objective and Tangible Measurement: The replacement cost model provides an objective and tangible measure of an asset's value. It focuses on the actual cost of replacing the asset with a similar one in the current market, which can be more straightforward and reliable compared to other valuation methods that rely on subjective estimates or market fluctuations.

2. Reflects Current Market Conditions: By considering current market prices, the replacement cost model reflects the prevailing economic conditions and market dynamics. It provides an up-to-date valuation that reflects the cost of acquiring a comparable asset in the current market, which can be particularly relevant in volatile markets or when market prices are rapidly changing.

3. Useful for Insurance Purposes: The replacement cost model is commonly used in insurance to determine the appropriate coverage and indemnity for assets. Insuring assets based on their replacement costs ensures that the policyholder can fully recover the cost of replacing the asset in the event of a covered loss or damage.

4. Straightforward and Easy to Understand: The replacement cost model is relatively simple and easy to understand. It involves assessing the current market prices of similar assets and calculating the cost of acquiring a replacement. This simplicity makes it accessible to individuals and organizations without extensive financial expertise.

Limitations of the Replacement Cost Model:

1. Ignores Appreciation or Depreciation: The replacement cost model focuses solely on the cost of replacing an asset and does not consider any appreciation or depreciation in the asset's value over time. It does not account for factors such as asset age, condition, technological advancements, or changes in market demand, which can impact an asset's actual market value.

2. Inaccurate for Unique or Specialized Assets: The replacement cost model may not provide an accurate valuation for unique or specialized assets that have limited availability in the market. If a comparable replacement is not readily available or if the market for the asset is illiquid, the replacement cost model may not accurately reflect the true value of the asset.

3. Excludes Consideration of Functional Obsolescence: The replacement cost model focuses on the physical replacement of an asset and does not account for functional obsolescence. Functional obsolescence refers to a reduction in an asset's value due to changes in technology, design, or market preferences. The replacement cost model may not capture the impact of functional obsolescence on an asset's value.

4. Limited Applicability for Unique Features or Intangibles: If an asset has unique features or intangible qualities that cannot be easily replaced or replicated, the replacement cost model may not accurately capture its value. The model's reliance on the cost of acquiring a similar asset may not account for the unique attributes or intangible value associated with the original asset.

5. Potential Cost Fluctuations: The replacement cost model assumes that the cost of acquiring a replacement asset remains constant. However, market conditions, supply and demand dynamics, and other factors can lead to fluctuations in replacement costs over time. Failure to account for these fluctuations may result in inaccurate valuations.

 

Q.4 A) Discuss the approaches to HR audit.                         08

HR audits help organizations evaluate and improve their human resource policies, practices, and compliance. The key approaches to HR audit include:

1. Comparative Approach

In this method, the organization’s HR practices are compared with:

• A leading organization in the same industry, or
• A set of best-practice standards.

This helps identify gaps and improvement areas.

How it works:

• Select a benchmark company known for strong HR practices.
• Compare HR activities like recruitment, training, performance appraisal, compensation and employee relations.
• Identify areas where the current organization is ahead or behind.

Advantages:

• Highlights competitive standing.
• Offers practical improvement ideas.

Limitations:

• Benchmarking company data may not always be accessible.
• Practices that work in one organization may not always work the same in another.

2. Compliance Approach

This approach measures whether the organization follows:

• Employment laws and regulations
• Government policies
• Health and safety rules
• Internal rules and HR policies

How it works:

• Review HR manuals, policy documents, employee records and contracts.
• Check whether procedures comply with laws on wages, working hours, employee rights and social security.
• Identify compliance gaps and risks.

Why organizations use it:

• Helps avoid legal penalties.
• Reduces unsafe or unethical practices.

3. Statistical Approach

In this method, HR performance is evaluated using measurable data.

Examples of HR metrics:

• Employee turnover rate
• Absenteeism rate
• Training hours per employee
• Cost per hire
• Performance appraisal scores
• Productivity per employee

How it works:

• Collect HR data for different periods.
• Analyse trends to evaluate effectiveness and efficiency.
• Detect problem areas based on changes in numbers.

Advantages:

• Objective and data-driven.
• Helps track improvements over time.

4. Outside Authority Approach

In this approach, the organization uses standards developed by an external agency such as:

• HR consulting firms
• Professional associations
• Government bodies
• Industry standard setters

These external standards act as the reference for evaluation.

Why this approach is useful:

• Helps bring objectivity.
• Provides professional and recognized guidelines.
• Useful when internal expertise is limited.

Drawback:

• Standards may not fully match internal culture or needs.

5. Management by Objectives (MBO) Approach

The audit checks how well HR achieved goals that were set earlier.

• HR sets targets at the beginning of the year.
  Examples:
• Reduce turnover by 10 percent.
• Improve training effectiveness.
• Fill vacancies within a defined time frame.
• At the end of the period, results are evaluated based on performance against these targets.

Features:

• Focuses on results and outcomes.
• Encourages accountability.
• Helps identify areas where HR needs to improve performance.

B) Explain objective of HR audit.                     07

The objective of an HR audit is to assess and evaluate the effectiveness, efficiency, and compliance of an organization's human resource practices, policies, and procedures. It aims to provide an objective and comprehensive analysis of the organization's HR function to identify strengths, weaknesses, areas of improvement, and potential risks. The primary objectives of conducting an HR audit are as follows:

1. Ensure legal compliance

One of the most important goals is to check whether the organization is following labor laws and government regulations. This includes rules related to wages, working hours, leave, safety, employee benefits, equal opportunity and other statutory requirements. The audit helps identify legal risks and prevents penalties or disputes later.

2. Evaluate effectiveness of HR policies and procedures

The audit checks whether HR policies are clear, updated and suitable for the organization. It reviews recruitment, training, performance appraisal, compensation, promotion, disciplinary procedures and other major functions. The idea is to see if these policies are helping the organization work smoothly and fairly.

3. Improve HR performance and efficiency

The audit looks at how HR activities are being carried out. It finds gaps, delays, wastage of resources and areas where processes can be improved. It helps HR become more systematic, organized and efficient.

4. Assess alignment with organizational goals

HR practices should support the mission, vision and growth plans of the company. The audit checks whether HR planning, staffing, employee development and retention strategies are helping the organization reach its long term goals.

5. Improve employee satisfaction and workplace culture

The audit reviews areas that affect employee morale such as communication, grievance handling, working conditions, welfare programs and fairness of HR systems. The aim is to create a work environment where employees feel supported and motivated.

6. Identify training and development needs

By examining employee performance and skill gaps, the audit helps HR understand where training is necessary. This ensures that employees grow and stay competitive.

7. Strengthen HR documentation and record keeping

Proper records are critical in HR for payroll, attendance, statutory compliance, safety, appraisals and career history. The audit checks whether documents are accurate, complete and stored properly.

8. Provide a roadmap for improvement

After identifying strengths and weaknesses, the HR audit provides suggestions and action plans that help the organization upgrade its HR function. It acts as a guide for continuous improvement.

9. Build accountability in the HR department

The audit creates clarity about who is responsible for what. It ensures that HR decisions are transparent, justified and can be reviewed when needed.

OR

Q.4 Explain in detail HR audit & work force issues.                15

HR audit is a systematic and comprehensive evaluation of an organization's human resource policies, procedures, practices, and strategies. It involves assessing the effectiveness, efficiency, compliance, and alignment of HR activities with the organization's goals and objectives. The HR audit helps identify areas of improvement, address potential risks, ensure legal compliance, and enhance overall HR performance. The audit can be conducted internally by the HR department or externally by third-party consultants. Here are the key aspects of an HR audit:

1. Assessment of HR Policies and Procedures: The audit examines the organization's HR policies and procedures to ensure they are up to date, legally compliant, and aligned with best practices. It involves reviewing policies related to recruitment and selection, compensation and benefits, performance management, training and development, employee relations, diversity and inclusion, and other HR areas.

2. Compliance Evaluation: Compliance is a critical aspect of an HR audit. It involves assessing whether the organization is adhering to relevant employment laws, labor regulations, health and safety standards, equal opportunity requirements, and data privacy regulations. Non-compliance issues are identified, and corrective actions are recommended to mitigate legal risks.

3. HR Process Review: The audit evaluates the effectiveness and efficiency of HR processes and procedures. This includes assessing the recruitment process, onboarding and orientation, training and development programs, performance management systems, compensation and benefits administration, employee engagement initiatives, and offboarding procedures.

4. Workforce Planning and Talent Management: The HR audit assesses the organization's workforce planning and talent management strategies. It examines the effectiveness of workforce planning processes, succession planning, talent acquisition and retention efforts, employee development programs, career progression opportunities, and diversity and inclusion initiatives.

5. HR Metrics and Analytics: The audit may involve analyzing HR metrics and analytics to evaluate the impact of HR initiatives on organizational performance. This includes measuring employee turnover rates, absenteeism, training and development effectiveness, employee satisfaction and engagement, productivity levels, and other relevant HR indicators.

6. HR Technology Assessment: The audit examines the organization's HR technology systems, including HRIS (Human Resource Information System) or HRMS (Human Resource Management System). It assesses the functionality, usability, and integration of these systems to support HR processes and data management.

7. Employee Relations and Communication: The audit evaluates employee relations practices, including grievance handling procedures, communication channels, employee feedback mechanisms, and employee recognition programs. It aims to identify areas for improvement to enhance employee satisfaction, engagement, and overall organizational climate.

Workforce Issues:

Workforce issues refer to challenges and concerns related to an organization's employees and the management of its workforce. These issues can impact organizational performance, productivity, employee satisfaction, and overall business success. Here are some common workforce issues:

1. Workforce Planning and Talent Shortages: Organizations may face challenges in effectively planning their workforce and addressing talent shortages. This includes identifying future workforce needs, attracting and retaining top talent, developing succession plans, and ensuring a pipeline of skilled employees to meet business demands.

2. Employee Engagement and Retention: Low employee engagement and high turnover rates can adversely affect organizational performance. Employee engagement issues may arise due to poor communication, lack of career development opportunities, insufficient recognition, and inadequate work-life balance. Retention challenges can be addressed through effective talent management strategies and initiatives.

3. Diversity and Inclusion: Organizations may face issues related to diversity and inclusion, including biases in recruitment and promotion processes, unequal opportunities for underrepresented groups, and a lack of inclusive workplace culture. Addressing these issues requires implementing diversity and inclusion programs, promoting awareness, and fostering an inclusive work environment.

4. Skills Gaps and Training Needs: Rapid technological advancements and evolving job roles may lead to skills gaps within the workforce. Organizations need to identify these gaps and provide appropriate training and development programs to enhance employee skills and competencies.

5. Employee Well-being and Work-Life Balance: Issues related to employee well-being, stress, and work-life balance can impact employee morale, productivity, and overall job satisfaction. Organizations should prioritize employee well-being by implementing policies and practices that support work-life balance, mental health, and a healthy work environment.

6. Change Management: Workforce issues can arise during organizational changes such as mergers, acquisitions, restructuring, or technological transformations. Managing these changes effectively requires effective communication, employee involvement, and support mechanisms to mitigate resistance and maintain employee morale.

Q.5 A) Explain the effectiveness of HRD audit as an intervention.    08

HRD (Human Resource Development) audit is an intervention that aims to assess the effectiveness of an organization's HRD practices and identify areas for improvement. It involves evaluating the alignment of HRD initiatives with organizational goals, analyzing the efficiency of HRD processes, and determining the impact of HRD interventions on employee development and performance. The effectiveness of HRD audit as an intervention can be seen through several key aspects:

1. Identification of Strengths and Weaknesses: HRD audit helps organizations identify their strengths and weaknesses in terms of HRD practices. By conducting a comprehensive assessment, organizations can identify areas where HRD initiatives are effective and aligned with business goals. It also highlights areas where improvements are needed to enhance the impact of HRD interventions.

2. Alignment with Organizational Goals: An effective HRD audit intervention ensures that HRD practices are aligned with the organization's overall objectives. By evaluating the connection between HRD initiatives and strategic goals, the audit helps organizations ensure that HRD interventions support and contribute to the achievement of business objectives.

3. Performance Improvement: HRD audit identifies areas where performance improvements can be made through targeted HRD interventions. By assessing the effectiveness of training programs, development initiatives, performance management systems, and career progression opportunities, organizations can enhance employee skills, knowledge, and performance.

4. Evaluation of HRD Processes: HRD audit evaluates the efficiency and effectiveness of HRD processes and procedures. It helps organizations identify bottlenecks, gaps, or inefficiencies in processes such as training needs analysis, training program design and delivery, performance evaluation, and career development. This evaluation enables organizations to streamline and improve their HRD processes to maximize the impact of interventions.

5. Identification of Training and Development Needs: Through HRD audit, organizations can identify the training and development needs of their employees. By assessing the existing skills and competencies of the workforce and comparing them with desired skill sets, organizations can design targeted training programs to bridge the gaps and enhance employee capabilities.

6. Benchmarking and Best Practices: HRD audit allows organizations to benchmark their HRD practices against industry best practices and standards. By comparing their HRD initiatives with those of other successful organizations, they can identify areas for improvement and implement best practices to enhance the effectiveness of their HRD interventions.

7. Strategic Decision-Making: HRD audit provides valuable data and insights that enable strategic decision-making related to HRD interventions. The audit findings help organizations prioritize HRD initiatives, allocate resources effectively, and make informed decisions about training investments, talent management strategies, leadership development programs, and other HRD interventions.

8. Continuous Improvement: HRD audit serves as a tool for continuous improvement in HRD practices. It allows organizations to assess the impact of their HRD interventions over time, monitor progress, and make necessary adjustments. By conducting periodic HRD audits, organizations can ensure ongoing evaluation, improvement, and alignment of their HRD initiatives with changing business needs.

While HRD audit offers several benefits as an intervention, it is important to note that its effectiveness depends on the commitment of the organization to act upon the audit findings and recommendations. Effective implementation of identified improvements and a commitment to continuous evaluation and improvement are crucial for realizing the full potential of HRD audit as an intervention.

B) Explain any one method of conducting HR auditing                   07

One method of conducting HR auditing is through a comprehensive review of HR policies and practices. This method involves examining and evaluating the organization's HR policies, procedures, and practices to ensure compliance, effectiveness, and alignment with business goals. Here's an overview of the steps involved in this method:

1. Establish the Scope and Objectives: Define the scope of the HR audit by identifying the specific areas and processes to be audited. Set clear objectives for the audit, such as assessing compliance, effectiveness, and alignment with organizational goals.

2. Collect Relevant HR Documentation: Gather all relevant HR documentation, including HR policies, employee handbooks, procedures manuals, employment contracts, training materials, performance management documents, and any other relevant HR records.

3. Review HR Policies and Procedures: Examine the organization's HR policies and procedures to assess their compliance with employment laws, regulations, and industry standards. Ensure that policies are up to date, legally compliant, and reflect best practices. Identify any gaps or inconsistencies in policies and recommend necessary revisions.

4. Evaluate HR Processes and Practices: Assess the effectiveness and efficiency of HR processes and practices. This includes reviewing recruitment and selection procedures, onboarding and orientation processes, training and development initiatives, performance management systems, compensation and benefits administration, employee relations procedures, and offboarding practices. Identify areas for improvement and recommend enhancements to streamline processes and improve outcomes.

5. Assess Compliance: Evaluate the organization's compliance with applicable laws, regulations, and industry standards. This includes reviewing compliance with employment laws, labor regulations, health and safety requirements, equal opportunity and diversity policies, data privacy regulations, and any other relevant legal obligations. Identify any non-compliance issues and recommend corrective actions.

6. Analyze HR Metrics and Data: Analyze HR metrics and data to gain insights into workforce trends, employee turnover rates, training effectiveness, performance evaluations, and other relevant HR indicators. Identify any patterns or areas of concern that require further investigation or improvement.

7. Conduct Interviews and Surveys: Conduct interviews and surveys with key stakeholders, including HR personnel, managers, and employees. Gather feedback on HR practices, employee experiences, and areas for improvement. This qualitative data provides valuable insights into the effectiveness and perception of HR initiatives.

8. Report Findings and Recommendations: Compile the findings of the HR audit into a comprehensive report. Summarize the strengths, weaknesses, and areas for improvement identified during the audit. Provide actionable recommendations to address the identified issues and enhance HR effectiveness, compliance, and alignment with business goals.

9. Implement Recommendations: Work with relevant stakeholders to implement the recommended improvements. Develop an action plan, assign responsibilities, and set timelines for implementing the recommended changes. Monitor the progress of implementation and ensure that the necessary adjustments are made.

10. Follow-Up and Review: Conduct follow-up reviews to assess the effectiveness of implemented changes and to monitor ongoing compliance and improvement efforts. Regularly review and update HR policies and practices to adapt to changing legal requirements and business needs.

 OR

Q.5 Write short notes on: (Any three)                               15

1) Orientation process of HR audit

The orientation process of an HR audit refers to the initial steps and preparation that organizations undertake before conducting the actual HR audit. It involves setting the stage, establishing goals, and defining the scope of the audit. Here's an overview of the orientation process for an HR audit:

1. Determine the Purpose and Objectives: Clearly define the purpose and objectives of the HR audit. Identify the specific areas of HR that will be audited, such as recruitment and selection, training and development, performance management, compensation and benefits, employee relations, or any other relevant HR functions. Establish the desired outcomes of the audit, such as identifying compliance gaps, assessing HR effectiveness, or improving HR processes.

2. Formulate an Audit Plan: Develop a comprehensive audit plan that outlines the steps, timeline, and resources required for the audit. Determine the audit team members and their roles and responsibilities. Assign a project manager or audit lead who will oversee the entire process and ensure its smooth execution.

3. Define the Scope and Boundaries: Clearly define the scope and boundaries of the HR audit. This involves identifying the departments, units, or locations within the organization that will be included in the audit. Consider factors such as organizational structure, geographical locations, or specific HR functions that need to be audited.

4. Identify Key Stakeholders: Identify the key stakeholders who will be involved in or affected by the HR audit. This includes HR personnel, senior management, department heads, and employees. Communicate with these stakeholders to explain the purpose of the audit, gain their support, and address any concerns or questions they may have.

5. Establish Audit Criteria and Standards: Determine the criteria and standards against which the HR practices will be assessed during the audit. This may include legal compliance, industry best practices, organizational policies, or specific performance indicators. Clearly communicate these criteria to the audit team and stakeholders to ensure consistency and alignment throughout the audit process.

6. Prepare Documentation and Data: Gather all relevant HR documentation and data that will be required for the audit. This includes HR policies and procedures, employment contracts, training materials, performance records, compensation and benefits information, employee engagement surveys, and any other relevant HR-related documents. Ensure that the documentation is up to date and organized for easy reference during the audit.

7. Develop Audit Tools and Templates: Develop audit tools and templates that will be used during the audit process. This may include checklists, questionnaires, interview guides, data analysis templates, or any other necessary tools for collecting and analyzing audit information. These tools should be designed to capture the specific areas and criteria identified for the audit.

8. Communicate the Audit Process: Clearly communicate the audit process to all relevant stakeholders. Provide information on the timeline, expectations, and the roles of different individuals involved in the audit. Explain the confidentiality and anonymity of the audit process to encourage open and honest feedback from employees.

9. Conduct Pre-Audit Meetings: Conduct pre-audit meetings with the audit team to ensure everyone understands their roles and responsibilities. Discuss the audit plan, methodology, and criteria. Address any questions or concerns raised by the team members and provide necessary clarifications.

10. Obtain Leadership Support: Gain support from senior management and leadership for the HR audit. Communicate the benefits of conducting the audit, such as improving HR effectiveness, enhancing compliance, and aligning HR practices with business goals. Secure the necessary resources and commitment from management to ensure the audit's success.

2) Pre-employment Requirements 

Pre-employment requirements refer to the documentation, checks, and processes that an organization requires from job applicants before finalizing their employment. These requirements are typically meant to verify the applicant's qualifications, suitability, and eligibility for the position. While specific pre-employment requirements may vary depending on the organization and the nature of the job, here are some common examples:

1. Application Form: Applicants are usually required to complete an application form that collects their personal information, employment history, education background, and other relevant details.

2. Resume/CV: Applicants are expected to submit a resume or curriculum vitae (CV) that highlights their qualifications, work experience, skills, and achievements.

3. Cover Letter: In some cases, applicants may be asked to provide a cover letter explaining their interest in the position and why they are a suitable candidate.

4. Educational Verification: Organizations often verify the educational qualifications claimed by applicants. This may involve requesting copies of educational certificates, transcripts, or contacting educational institutions directly to verify the information.

5. Employment Verification: Organizations may conduct employment verification to confirm an applicant's work history, positions held, job responsibilities, and employment dates. This may involve contacting previous employers or asking for references.

6. Background Checks: Background checks are commonly conducted to assess an applicant's criminal record, credit history, and other relevant background information. This is typically done to ensure the safety and security of the workplace and to make informed hiring decisions.

7. Reference Checks: Employers may contact the references provided by applicants to gather information about their past performance, work ethic, and professional conduct.

8. Drug and Alcohol Testing: Some organizations may require applicants to undergo drug and alcohol testing as part of the pre-employment process to ensure a safe and drug-free work environment.

9. Medical Examination: Certain jobs may require applicants to undergo a medical examination to assess their physical and mental fitness to perform the job duties effectively and safely.

10. Legal Authorization to Work: Applicants are typically required to provide proof of legal authorization to work in the country where the job is located. This may involve providing documents such as a valid work visa, work permit, or citizenship/residency status.

11. Skills Assessment/Testing: Depending on the nature of the job, applicants may be required to undergo skills assessments or testing to evaluate their proficiency in specific areas relevant to the job.

3) Questionnaire method

The questionnaire method is a data collection technique used in research and various fields to gather information from individuals or groups. It involves presenting a series of questions to respondents, who then provide written or verbal responses. The questionnaire method is a structured approach that allows for standardized data collection and can be administered in various formats, such as paper-based questionnaires, online surveys, or interviews. Here are some key points about the questionnaire method:

1. Designing the Questionnaire: The first step in the questionnaire method is to design the questionnaire itself. This involves determining the objectives of the study, identifying the target population or sample, and formulating clear and concise questions. The questions should be well-structured, unbiased, and relevant to the research objectives. The questionnaire may include closed-ended questions (multiple-choice or Likert scale), open-ended questions, or a combination of both.

2. Pilot Testing: Before administering the questionnaire to the target population, it is advisable to conduct a pilot test. This involves testing the questionnaire on a small sample to assess its clarity, comprehension, and overall effectiveness. Feedback from the pilot test participants can help identify any issues or areas for improvement before the actual data collection.

3. Administering the Questionnaire: The questionnaire can be administered through various methods, such as distributing paper-based questionnaires, sending online surveys via email or web platforms, or conducting face-to-face interviews. The method chosen depends on factors such as the target population, accessibility, and practical considerations.

4. Data Collection: During the data collection phase, respondents complete the questionnaire by providing their responses to the questions. Researchers or administrators may provide instructions or guidance to ensure respondents understand the questions and how to answer them. It is important to maintain confidentiality and anonymity if desired, to encourage honest and unbiased responses.

5. Data Analysis: Once the data collection is complete, the next step is to analyze the data obtained from the questionnaire responses. Depending on the nature of the questions and the research objectives, various statistical and qualitative analysis techniques can be applied. Closed-ended questions can be analyzed using quantitative methods, while open-ended questions may require qualitative analysis techniques such as content analysis or thematic coding.

Advantages of the Questionnaire Method:

- Standardization: Questionnaires allow for standardized data collection, ensuring that all respondents are presented with the same set of questions and response options. This facilitates data comparison and analysis.

- Large Sample Size: Questionnaires can be administered to a large number of respondents simultaneously, allowing for a larger sample size, which can increase the representativeness and generalizability of the findings.

- Cost-Effectiveness: Compared to other data collection methods, questionnaires are often a cost-effective option, especially when administered online or through self-administered paper forms.

- Anonymity and Privacy: Respondents have the option to maintain their anonymity and privacy when 

completing the questionnaire, which can encourage more honest and unbiased responses.

Limitations of the Questionnaire Method:

- Response Bias: Respondents may provide inaccurate or biased responses due to social desirability bias, recall bias, or interpretation errors. Careful questionnaire design and clear instructions can help minimize these biases.

- Limited Depth of Information: Questionnaires are typically limited in the depth of information they can gather compared to other qualitative methods such as interviews or focus groups. Open-ended questions can help address this limitation to some extent.

- Lack of Clarification: Questionnaires do not allow for real-time clarification of questions or misunderstandings that respondents may have, unlike in interviews or discussions. This can lead to incomplete or misunderstood responses.

- Low Response Rates: The response rate for questionnaires can vary, and low response rates may introduce non-response bias if the respondents differ systematically from non-respondents. Strategies such as reminders and incentives can be used to improve response rates.

4) Capitalization of Salary 

Salary capitalization, also known as labor capitalization, is an accounting method where a portion of an employee's salary and related expenses are recorded as an asset on the balance sheet instead of being expensed on the income statement in the period they are incurred. This practice is typically applied when an employee's work directly contributes to the creation of a long-term asset, such as software development, building construction, or research and development projects.

In essence, the rationale behind salary capitalization is that the employee's efforts are creating future economic benefits for the company. Therefore, it's more appropriate to allocate the cost of their labor to the asset being created rather than immediately expensing it.

Advantages of Salary Capitalization

Capitalizing salary can offer several potential advantages for companies:

• Improved Matching Principle: It aligns the expense of labor with the revenue generated by the asset created. This provides a more accurate representation of the company's profitability over the asset's useful life.
• Enhanced Financial Ratios: Capitalizing salary can improve key financial ratios, such as the return on assets (ROA) and the profit margin. This is because the expense is deferred, leading to higher reported profits in the short term.
• Tax Benefits: In some jurisdictions, capitalizing salary may result in tax benefits. The capitalized costs can be depreciated over the asset's useful life, providing a tax deduction over time.
• More Accurate Asset Valuation: It provides a more accurate representation of the true cost of an asset. This is particularly important for assets that are internally developed, as it captures the labor costs associated with their creation.
• Attractiveness to Investors: Showing a higher profit margin can make the company more attractive to investors.

Disadvantages of Salary Capitalization

Despite the potential benefits, salary capitalization also has several disadvantages:

• Increased Complexity: It adds complexity to the accounting process. Companies need to implement robust time tracking and cost allocation systems to ensure accurate capitalization.
• Subjectivity: Determining the portion of salary to be capitalized can be subjective, especially when employees work on multiple projects. This can lead to inconsistencies and potential manipulation.
• Potential for Overstatement of Assets: If not done carefully, salary capitalization can lead to an overstatement of assets on the balance sheet. This can mislead investors and creditors about the company's financial health.
• Reduced Current Profitability: While it improves long-term profitability, it reduces current profitability. This may be a concern for companies that are focused on short-term results.
• Compliance Costs: Implementing and maintaining a salary capitalization system can be costly, especially for small businesses.
• Risk of Write-Downs: If the asset being created does not generate the expected economic benefits, the capitalized costs may need to be written down, resulting in a significant loss.

5) Historical cost approach

Historical cost is an accounting principle that requires companies to record assets and liabilities at their original purchase price. This means that the value of an asset on the balance sheet remains the same, regardless of any subsequent changes in its market value. For example, if a company purchases a piece of equipment for $10,000, it will be recorded on the balance sheet at $10,000, even if its market value later increases to $12,000 or decreases to $8,000.

The historical cost principle applies not only to tangible assets like property, plant, and equipment (PP&E) but also to intangible assets like patents and trademarks. Liabilities are also recorded at the amount of proceeds received in exchange for the obligation, adjusted for amortization or accretion.

Advantages of Historical Cost

Several advantages contribute to the enduring popularity of historical cost accounting:

1. Objectivity and Verifiability

One of the most significant advantages of historical cost is its objectivity. The original purchase price is a verifiable fact, supported by invoices, receipts, and other documentation. This reduces the potential for subjective judgments and biases in financial reporting. External auditors can easily verify the historical cost of an asset by examining these supporting documents, providing a high degree of assurance about the accuracy of the reported figures.

2. Reliability

Because historical cost is based on actual transactions, it is considered a reliable measure of value. Unlike fair value accounting, which relies on estimates and market conditions, historical cost provides a stable and consistent basis for financial reporting. This reliability is particularly important for users of financial statements who rely on the information to make informed decisions.

3. Simplicity and Ease of Application

Historical cost accounting is relatively simple to apply. It does not require complex valuation models or frequent revaluations. This makes it easier and less costly for companies to maintain their accounting records. The straightforward nature of historical cost also reduces the potential for errors and inconsistencies in financial reporting.

4. Understandability

The concept of historical cost is generally easy for users of financial statements to understand. Most people are familiar with the idea of recording assets at their original purchase price. This enhances the transparency and credibility of financial reporting. Users can readily grasp the basis for the reported values and make informed judgments about a company's financial position.

5. Conservatism

Historical cost aligns with the principle of conservatism in accounting. Assets are not revalued upwards until they are sold, but they are often written down if their value declines below the historical cost. This approach avoids overstating assets and income, providing a more cautious and realistic view of a company's financial performance.

6. Reduced Volatility

Using historical cost reduces the volatility of reported earnings and equity. Fair value accounting, which requires assets and liabilities to be revalued to their current market values, can lead to significant fluctuations in financial statements due to market volatility. Historical cost provides a more stable and predictable picture of a company's financial performance over time.

7. Comparability

Historical cost enhances the comparability of financial statements across different companies and over different time periods. Because assets are recorded at their original purchase price, it is easier to compare the financial performance of companies that have acquired similar assets at different times. This comparability is essential for investors and analysts who use financial statements to evaluate and compare different investment opportunities.

Limitations of the Historical Cost Approach:

1. Value Relevance

The historical cost approach may not reflect the current economic value or fair market value of assets and liabilities. In periods of significant inflation or deflation, the historical cost values may not accurately represent the economic reality.

2. Overstatement or Understatement

Over time, the historical cost of assets may become significantly different from their current market values. This can lead to the overstatement or understatement of the assets' true economic worth.

3. Limited Decision Usefulness

The historical cost approach may limit the decision usefulness of financial statements, as it does not provide information about changes in the value of assets or potential gains or losses that have not been realized.

4. Depreciation and Amortization

The historical cost approach requires the recognition of depreciation or amortization expense over the useful life of assets. However, this may not fully reflect the assets' actual loss in value over time.

Elective: Operation Research (CBCGS)
Year	Month	Q.P.	Link
IMP Q.			Solution
Obj. Q			Solution
2019	April	Download	Solution
2019	November	Download	Solution
2022	November	Download	Solution
2023	April	Download	Solution
2023	November	Download	Solution
2024	April	Download	Solution
2024	November		Solution
2025	April

Elective: International Finance (CBCGS)
Year	Month	Q.P.	Link
IMP Q.			Solution
Obj. Q			Solution
2019	April	Download	Solution
2019	November	Download	Solution
2022	November	Download	Solution
2023	April	Download	Solution
2024	April	Download	Solution
2024	November	Download	Solution
2025	April

Elective: Brand Management (CBCGS)
Year	Month	Q.P.	Link
IMP Q.			Solution
Obj. Q			Solution
2019	April	Download	Solution
2019	November	Download	Solution
2023	April	Download	Solution
2024	April	Download	Solution
2024	November	Download	Solution
2025	April		Solution

Elective: HRM in Global Perspective (CBCGS)
Year	Month	Q.P.	Link
IMP Q.			Solution
Obj. Q			Solution
2019	April	Download	Solution
2019	November	Download	Solution
2023	April	Download	Solution
2024	April	Download	Solution
2024	November	Download	Solution
2025	April

Elective: Innovation Financial Service (CBCGS)
Year	Month	Q.P.	Link
IMP Q.			Solution
Obj. Q			Solution
2019	April	Download	Solution
2019	November	Download	Solution
2023	April	Download	Solution
2024	April	Download	Solution
2024	November	Download	Solution
2025	April		Solution

Elective: Retail Management (CBCGS)
Year	Month	Q.P.	Link
IMP Q.			Solution
Obj. Q			Solution
2019	April	Download	Solution
2019	November	Download	Solution
2023	April	Download	Solution
2024	April	Download	Solution
2024	November	Download
2025	April

Elective: Organizational Development (CBCGS)
Year	Month	Q.P.	Link
IMP Q.			Solution
Obj. Q			Solution
2019	April	Download	Solution
2019	November	Download	Solution
2023	April	Download	Solution
2024	April	Download	Solution
2024	November	Download	Solution
2025	April

Elective: Project Management (CBCGS)
Year	Month	Q.P.	Link
IMP Q.			Solution
Obj. Q			Solution
2019	April	Download	Solution
2019	November	Download	Solution
2023	April	Download	Solution
2024	April	Download	Solution
2024	November	Download	Solution
2025	April

Elective: International Marketing (CBCGS)
Year	Month	Q.P.	Link
IMP Q.			Solution
Obj. Q			Solution
2019	April	Download	Solution
2019	November	Download	Solution
2023	April	Download	Solution
2024	April	Download	Solution
2024	November	Download
2025	April

Elective: HRM in Service Sector Management (CBCGS)
Year	Month	Q.P.	Link
IMP Q.			Solution
Obj. Q			Solution
2019	April	Download	Solution
2019	November	Download	Solution
2023	April	Download	Solution
2024	April	Download	Solution
2024	November	Download
2025	April

Elective: Strategic Financial Management (CBCGS)
Year	Month	Q.P.	Link
IMP Q.			Solution
Obj. Q			Solution
2019	April	Download	Solution
2019	November	Download	Solution
2023	April	Download	Solution
2024	April	Download	Solution
2024	November	Download	Solution
2025	April

Elective: Media Planning (CBCGS)
Year	Month	Q.P.	Link
IMP Q.			Solution
Obj. Q			Solution
2019	April	Download	Solution
2019	November	Download	Solution
2023	April	Download	Solution
2024	April	Download	Solution
2024	November	Download	Solution
2025	April

Elective: Workforce Diversity (CBCGS)
Year	Month	Q.P.	Link
IMP Q.			Solution
Obj. Q			Solution
2023	April	Download	Solution
2024	April	Download	Solution
2024	November	Download
2025	April

Elective: Financing Rural Development (CBCGS)
Year	Month	Q.P.	Link
IMP Q.			Solution
Obj. Q			Solution
2023	April	Download	Solution
2024	April	Download	Solution
2024	November	Download
2025	April

Elective: Sport Marketing (CBCGS)
Year	Month	Q.P.	Link
IMP Q.			Solution
Obj. Q			Solution
2023	April	Download	Solution
2024	April	Download	Solution
2024	November	Download
2025	April

Elective: HRM Accounting & Audit (CBCGS)
Year	Month	Q.P.	Link
IMP Q.			Solution
Obj. Q			Solution
2019	April	Download	Solution
2019	November	Download	Solution
2023	April	Download	Solution
2024	April	Download	Solution
2024	November	Download	Solution
2025	April

Elective: Indirect Tax (CBCGS)
Year	Month	Q.P.	Link
IMP Q.			Solution
Obj. Q			Solution
2019	April	Download	Solution
2019	November	Download	Solution
2023	April	Download	Solution
2024	April	Download	Solution
2024	November	Download	Solution
2025	April

Elective: Marketing of Non-Profit Organization (CBCGS)
Year	Month	Q.P.	Link
IMP Q.			Solution
Obj. Q			Solution
2019	April	Download	Solution
2019	November	Download	Solution
2023	April	Download	Solution
2024	April	Download	Solution
2024	November	Download	Solution
2025	April

Elective: Indian Ethos in Management (CBCGS)
Year	Month	Q.P.	Link
IMP Q.			Solution
Obj. Q			Solution
2019	April	Download	Solution
2019	November	Download	Solution
2023	April	Download	Solution
2024	April	Download	Solution
2024	November	Download	Solution
2025	April