TYBMS SEM-6 Human Resource: Human Resource Accounting & Audit (QP April 2023 with Solutions)

 Paper / Subject Code: 86016/ Elective: Human Resource: Human Resource Accounting & Audit

TYBMS SEM-6 

Human Resource: 

Human Resource Accounting & Audit 

(QP April 2023 with Solutions)

Please check whether you have got the right question paper.

N.B: 1) All questions are compulsory.

2) Figures to the right indicate marks.

Q1. (A) Select the correct answer from the multiple choice questions (Any 8)    [8]

1. Human resources are considered as important _________

a. Liabilities

b. Assets 

c. Income

d. Expense

2. HRA shows human resource as ________ and not expense.

a. Capital

b. Liabilities

c. Income

d. Bad debts

3. In 1960's, _______ along with other social researchers made an attempt to define the concept of human resource accounting.

a. Rensis Likert

b. Malcolm Baldrige

c. Ishikawa Kauru

d. Stephen Knauf

4. _______ is calculated as Basic DA x No. of years of service x 15/26. 

a. Pension

b. Salary

c. TDS

d. Gratuity

5) ________ method involves drawing inferences from various senses that are seen. and heard off in day to day life,

a. Questionnaire.

b. Observation

c. Workshop

d. Interview

6. All actual cost incurred on recruitment, training, familiarization are capitalized in _______ cost method

a. Historical

b Economic

c. Replacement

d. Opportunity

7. HR valuation report helps the management to control all _______ related to HR department

a. Income

b. Loss

c. Profit

d. Cost

8. The object of modern audit is to report on ________ position.

a. Market 

b. Social

c. Financial

d. Present

9. _______ audits are conducted at regular intervals.

a. Ad hoc

b. Periodic

c. Internal

d. External

10. _________ is a man-made art and its principles and procedures have been evolved over a period of time.

a. Accounting

b. Human

c. Animals

d. Money

Q1. (B) State whether following statements are True or False (Any 7)            (7)

1. Replacement method is a non-monetary method of human valuation.

Ans: False

2. Economic value method takes into account the valuation made by the human resources to the organization.

Ans: True

3. Human resource audit can be used as an intervention to bring about organizational change.

Ans: True

4. Workshop method of conducting HR audit is very rigid.

Ans: False

5. HR audit helps in increasing the human resource cost. 

Ans: False

6. Result of HR audit can be expressed in measurable terms.

Ans: True

7. Historical cost accounting concepts are unrealistic profit.

Ans: True

8. Professional tax or employment tax is a state base tax.

Ans: True

9. The valuation of human assets is based on the assumption that employees are going to remain with the organization for a specified period. 

Ans: True

10. The valuations of human resources along with other assets are necessary in order to find out the total cost of an organization.

Ans: True

Q.2.A) Discuss the objective of HR accounting.                (08)

The primary objective of Human Resource Accounting (HRA) is to provide management and other stakeholders with relevant and reliable information about the value of an organization's human resources. This information is intended to improve decision-making related to human resource management and to provide a more complete picture of the organization's financial position and performance. This overarching objective can be broken down into several key sub-objectives:

1. Identifying and Measuring the Value of Human Resources

One of the fundamental objectives of HRA is to identify and measure the value of an organization's human resources. This involves determining the costs associated with recruiting, hiring, training, and developing employees, as well as assessing the economic value of their skills, knowledge, and abilities.

• Cost Measurement: HRA aims to quantify all costs related to human resources, including direct costs (e.g., salaries, wages, benefits) and indirect costs (e.g., recruitment expenses, training costs, employee development programs).

• Value Assessment: HRA seeks to determine the economic value of employees' contributions to the organization. This can be done through various methods, such as assessing the present value of future earnings, measuring the return on investment in human capital, or evaluating the impact of employee performance on organizational outcomes.

2. Facilitating Better Decision-Making

HRA aims to provide management with the information needed to make more informed decisions about human resource management. By quantifying the value of human resources, HRA can help managers:

• Optimize Staffing Levels: HRA can help managers determine the optimal number of employees needed to achieve organizational goals, as well as identify areas where staffing levels may be too high or too low.

• Improve Recruitment and Selection: By tracking the costs and benefits of different recruitment and selection methods, HRA can help managers identify the most effective ways to attract and hire qualified employees.

• Enhance Training and Development: HRA can help managers evaluate the effectiveness of training and development programs by measuring the return on investment in human capital.

• Increase Employee Retention: By identifying the factors that contribute to employee turnover, HRA can help managers develop strategies to improve employee retention and reduce the costs associated with employee turnover.

3. Improving Organizational Efficiency and Productivity

By providing insights into the value of human resources, HRA can help organizations improve their efficiency and productivity. This can be achieved by:

• Identifying Areas for Improvement: HRA can help organizations identify areas where human resource management practices can be improved to enhance employee performance and productivity.

• Promoting Employee Engagement: By demonstrating the value of employees to the organization, HRA can help promote employee engagement and motivation, leading to increased productivity and improved organizational outcomes.

• Optimizing Resource Allocation: HRA can help organizations allocate resources more effectively by identifying the areas where investments in human capital will generate the greatest return.

4. Providing a More Complete Picture of Organizational Value

Traditional accounting methods typically focus on tangible assets, such as property, plant, and equipment. HRA seeks to provide a more complete picture of organizational value by including the value of human resources, which are often a significant asset for many organizations.

• Enhanced Financial Reporting: HRA can provide stakeholders with a more accurate and comprehensive view of the organization's financial position and performance by including the value of human resources in financial reports.

• Improved Stakeholder Communication: HRA can help organizations communicate the value of their human resources to stakeholders, such as investors, creditors, and employees, thereby enhancing trust and confidence in the organization.

• Attracting and Retaining Investors: By demonstrating the value of human resources, HRA can help organizations attract and retain investors who recognize the importance of human capital in driving organizational success.

5. Supporting Human Resource Planning and Control

HRA provides a framework for planning and controlling human resource activities. By quantifying the costs and benefits of human resource programs, HRA can help managers:

• Develop Human Resource Budgets: HRA can help managers develop realistic and effective human resource budgets by providing data on the costs of various human resource activities.

• Monitor Human Resource Performance: HRA can help managers monitor the performance of human resource programs and identify areas where improvements are needed.

• Evaluate Human Resource Investments: HRA can help managers evaluate the return on investment in human resource programs and make informed decisions about future investments.

B) Discuss the various stages in Historical development of HRA.        (07)

Human Resource Accounting (HRA) did not develop all at once. It emerged gradually through several stages as scholars, economists, and organizations began to recognize that people are valuable resources worth measuring. Below is a detailed discussion of the major stages in the historical development of HRA:

1. Early Conceptual Stage (1960s)

The roots of HRA can be traced to the early 1960s when economists started questioning why traditional accounting ignored human resources even though employees contributed significantly to organizational success.
During this period:

• The idea of valuing human beings as assets was first proposed.

• Researchers began exploring whether the cost of hiring, training, and development should be capitalized rather than treated as expenses.

• Rensis Likert and his associates at the University of Michigan played a major role by studying how better human resource reporting could support management decisions.

This stage laid the intellectual foundation for the later development of models and measurement systems.

2. Development of Valuation Models (Late 1960s to Early 1970s)

Once the concept gained academic interest, researchers began designing methods to value human resources numerically.
Some major contributions in this stage were:

• Brummet, Flamholtz and Pyle introduced the term “Human Resource Accounting” in 1968.

• Researchers developed both cost-based and value-based models.

• The cost-based approach included:

  • Acquisition cost

  • Replacement cost

  • Training and development cost

• Value-based models tried to estimate how much future benefits employees would bring to the organization.

This era was important because it provided structured techniques to measure employees in financial terms.

3. Experimental and Corporate Adoption Stage (1970s)

In the 1970s, several large organizations in the United States, India, and Europe began experimenting with HRA in real-world settings. Examples include:

• R.G. Barry Corporation in the United States, which published human resource value in its annual report.

• Various public enterprises in India also began reporting HRA figures.

During this stage:

• Organizations applied HRA models to see whether the results improved management decisions.

• Reports included recruitment cost, training cost, staff turnover value, and employee contribution.

• HRA became a subject of academic teaching and research in many universities.

Although adoption was limited, this period showed that HRA could be used in practice and not just theory.

4. Decline in Corporate Enthusiasm (Late 1970s to 1980s)

By the late 1970s and early 1980s, interest in HRA slowed down. The decline happened for several reasons:

• Many companies found the system complex and expensive to maintain.

• Valuation methods lacked standardization, making figures difficult to compare.

• Accounting regulators did not allow human asset values to appear in the balance sheet.

• Human valuation numbers changed frequently and required regular updating.

As a result, although universities continued teaching the subject, fewer corporations implemented it in practice.

5. Revival with Strategic HR and Knowledge Economy (1990s onwards)

From the 1990s, HRA regained relevance due to major changes in business and the economy:

• Organizations became more knowledge driven.

• The value of intellectual capital, innovation, and employee skills became more important than physical assets.

• Strategic Human Resource Management (SHRM) emphasized measuring human contribution for competitive advantage.

• New reporting frameworks, such as:

  • Balanced Scorecard

  • Human Capital Reporting guides

  • Competency-based performance measurement

brought the focus back toward human value.

During this stage, companies and researchers expanded HRA to include:

• Workforce productivity metrics

• Employee engagement reports

• Intellectual capital valuation

• Human capital return on investment

6. Modern Stage: Integration with Technology and Analytics (2000s to Present)

Today, HRA continues evolving with advanced analytics, HR information systems, and big data. Modern trends include:

• Use of HR Analytics to forecast employee performance, turnover, and contribution.

• Integration of human capital reporting in sustainability and ESG reports.

• Global organizations publishing human resource disclosures in annual reports.

• AI-based tools measuring workforce value more accurately.

Although full recognition in financial statements is still limited, companies now use HRA for:

• Internal performance evaluation

• Investment in employee development

• Workforce planning

• Decision making at strategic levels

OR

P) Explain the components, of acquisition cost and training and development cost         (8) 

Acquisition cost refers to the total expenses incurred by an organization in the process of recruiting, selecting, and hiring a new employee. It encompasses all costs associated with attracting candidates, evaluating their qualifications, and onboarding them into the company. A thorough understanding of acquisition costs allows organizations to make informed decisions about their hiring strategies and optimize their recruitment processes. The major components of acquisition cost are detailed below:

1. Recruitment Costs

These are the expenses directly related to attracting potential candidates to apply for open positions. They include:

• Advertising Costs: This covers the cost of placing job advertisements on various platforms, such as online job boards (e.g., LinkedIn, Indeed), company websites, social media, newspapers, and industry-specific publications. The cost varies depending on the platform, the reach of the advertisement, and the duration of the campaign.

• Agency Fees: Many organizations utilize recruitment agencies or headhunters to source qualified candidates, especially for specialized or senior-level positions. These agencies charge a fee, typically a percentage of the candidate's first-year salary, for their services.

• Recruiter Salaries and Expenses: This includes the salaries, benefits, and travel expenses of internal recruiters who are responsible for sourcing, screening, and interviewing candidates.

• Job Fair Costs: Participating in job fairs can be an effective way to reach a large pool of potential candidates. Costs associated with job fairs include booth rental, travel expenses for recruiters, and promotional materials.

• Employee Referral Bonuses: Many companies offer bonuses to employees who refer successful candidates. These bonuses can be a significant component of recruitment costs.

• Online Recruitment Platform Subscriptions: Companies often subscribe to online recruitment platforms to access candidate databases and streamline the application process.

2. Selection Costs

These are the expenses incurred in evaluating the qualifications of candidates and selecting the most suitable individual for the job. They include:

• Application Processing Costs: This covers the cost of processing applications, including data entry, screening resumes, and responding to applicants.

• Testing Costs: Many organizations use various tests, such as aptitude tests, personality assessments, and skills tests, to evaluate candidates' abilities and suitability for the role. These tests can incur costs for administration, scoring, and interpretation.

• Interview Costs: This includes the time spent by hiring managers and other employees conducting interviews, as well as any travel expenses incurred by candidates for in-person interviews.

• Background Checks: Conducting background checks, including criminal history checks, employment verification, and education verification, is a crucial step in the selection process. These checks can incur costs depending on the scope and depth of the investigation.

• Assessment Center Costs: For some positions, organizations may use assessment centers to evaluate candidates' skills and abilities through simulations, group exercises, and other activities. These centers can incur significant costs for facilities, materials, and assessors.

3. Hiring and Onboarding Costs

These are the expenses associated with formally hiring the selected candidate and integrating them into the organization. They include:

• HR Administrative Costs: This covers the time spent by HR staff processing paperwork, creating employee files, and completing other administrative tasks related to hiring.

• Onboarding Program Costs: Onboarding programs are designed to help new employees acclimate to the company culture, understand their roles and responsibilities, and build relationships with colleagues. These programs can incur costs for materials, training, and employee time.

• New Employee Paperwork and System Setup: This includes the cost of preparing employment contracts, setting up employee accounts in HR systems, and providing necessary equipment and resources.

• Relocation Costs: If the new employee needs to relocate for the job, the organization may cover some or all of the relocation expenses, such as moving costs, temporary housing, and travel expenses.

Training and Development Cost

Training and development costs encompass all expenses incurred by an organization in providing employees with the knowledge, skills, and abilities necessary to perform their jobs effectively and advance their careers. Investing in training and development is crucial for improving employee performance, increasing productivity, and retaining talent. The major components of training and development costs are detailed below:

1. Direct Training Costs

These are the expenses directly related to delivering training programs. They include:

• Trainer Salaries and Fees: This covers the salaries of internal trainers or the fees paid to external consultants or training providers.

• Training Materials Costs: This includes the cost of developing and producing training materials, such as manuals, workbooks, videos, and online resources.

• Facility Costs: If training is conducted in a dedicated training facility, this includes the cost of renting or maintaining the facility, as well as utilities and equipment.

• Equipment Costs: This covers the cost of purchasing or renting equipment used for training, such as computers, projectors, and simulation devices.

• Travel and Accommodation Costs: If employees need to travel to attend training programs, this includes the cost of transportation, accommodation, and meals.

2. Indirect Training Costs

These are the expenses that are not directly related to delivering training programs but are still necessary for supporting training activities. They include:

• Employee Salaries During Training: This represents the cost of paying employees their regular salaries while they are attending training programs.

• Lost Productivity: While employees are in training, they are not performing their regular job duties, which can result in a temporary loss of productivity.

• Administrative Costs: This covers the time spent by HR staff and other employees planning, organizing, and administering training programs.

• Evaluation Costs: This includes the cost of evaluating the effectiveness of training programs, such as conducting surveys, analyzing performance data, and gathering feedback from participants.

3. Development Costs

These are the expenses associated with providing employees with opportunities for long-term growth and development. They include:

• Mentoring Program Costs: This covers the time spent by mentors providing guidance and support to mentees, as well as any training or resources provided to mentors.

• Coaching Program Costs: This includes the fees paid to external coaches or the time spent by internal coaches providing individualized support to employees.

• Tuition Reimbursement: Many organizations offer tuition reimbursement programs to encourage employees to pursue further education or professional certifications.

• Conference and Workshop Fees: This covers the cost of employees attending industry conferences, workshops, and seminars to learn new skills and network with peers.

• Leadership Development Programs: These programs are designed to develop the leadership skills of employees and prepare them for future leadership roles. They can incur significant costs for training, coaching, and assessment.

Q) List and explain any 5 shortcomings/limitations of Human Resource accounting         (7)

1. Difficulty in measuring human value

Human knowledge, skills, creativity, attitude, and potential are not physical assets that can be easily quantified. People develop over time, and how much value they create can depend on many factors like motivation, health, culture, leadership, and teamwork. Because of this, any financial value placed on employees is partly subjective. Two evaluators may value the same employee very differently, which weakens the reliability of the figures produced.

2. Lack of universally accepted standards

Unlike traditional accounting for equipment or buildings, there is no single agreed-upon system for valuing human resources. Different organizations may use cost-based models, opportunity cost methods, productivity models, or a combination of approaches. This leads to inconsistent results across companies, industries, and countries. Without standardized rules, Human Resource Accounting is difficult for regulators, analysts, and investors to rely on or compare across firms.

3. May be seen as dehumanizing

Employees may feel uncomfortable being assigned a financial value like a piece of machinery. It can give the impression that people are assets to be bought, used, and replaced rather than individuals with dignity and uniqueness. This perception may also affect trust and workplace culture. Many argue that reducing human contribution to a monetary figure ignores emotions, relationships, loyalty, and social responsibility, which are essential to organizational success.

4. Human values fluctuate rapidly

Unlike a machine that loses value steadily over time, the value of employees can rise or fall unexpectedly. Training, promotions, motivation, physical and mental health, family circumstances, new technology, or changes in job roles can all affect employee contribution. Because of this, valuations need constant updating if they are to stay accurate. This makes the system complicated to maintain and can raise the cost of implementation.

5. Limited use in statutory financial reporting

Most national and international accounting standards do not allow human resource values to appear on balance sheets. This means even if a company spends time calculating the value of its people, those numbers generally appear only in internal reports or supplemental disclosures. Investors and lenders may not rely on them for decision making. As a result, organizations may feel there is little incentive to invest heavily in such systems, limiting wider adoption.

Q3 A) Define and explain the advantages of historical cost.        (8)

Historical cost is an accounting principle that requires companies to record assets and liabilities at their original purchase price. This means that the value of an asset on the balance sheet remains the same, regardless of any subsequent changes in its market value. For example, if a company purchases a piece of equipment for $10,000, it will be recorded on the balance sheet at $10,000, even if its market value later increases to $12,000 or decreases to $8,000.

The historical cost principle applies not only to tangible assets like property, plant, and equipment (PP&E) but also to intangible assets like patents and trademarks. Liabilities are also recorded at the amount of proceeds received in exchange for the obligation, adjusted for amortization or accretion.

Advantages of Historical Cost

Several advantages contribute to the enduring popularity of historical cost accounting:

1. Objectivity and Verifiability

One of the most significant advantages of historical cost is its objectivity. The original purchase price is a verifiable fact, supported by invoices, receipts, and other documentation. This reduces the potential for subjective judgments and biases in financial reporting. External auditors can easily verify the historical cost of an asset by examining these supporting documents, providing a high degree of assurance about the accuracy of the reported figures.

2. Reliability

Because historical cost is based on actual transactions, it is considered a reliable measure of value. Unlike fair value accounting, which relies on estimates and market conditions, historical cost provides a stable and consistent basis for financial reporting. This reliability is particularly important for users of financial statements who rely on the information to make informed decisions.

3. Simplicity and Ease of Application

Historical cost accounting is relatively simple to apply. It does not require complex valuation models or frequent revaluations. This makes it easier and less costly for companies to maintain their accounting records. The straightforward nature of historical cost also reduces the potential for errors and inconsistencies in financial reporting.

4. Understandability

The concept of historical cost is generally easy for users of financial statements to understand. Most people are familiar with the idea of recording assets at their original purchase price. This enhances the transparency and credibility of financial reporting. Users can readily grasp the basis for the reported values and make informed judgments about a company's financial position.

5. Conservatism

Historical cost aligns with the principle of conservatism in accounting. Assets are not revalued upwards until they are sold, but they are often written down if their value declines below the historical cost. This approach avoids overstating assets and income, providing a more cautious and realistic view of a company's financial performance.

6. Reduced Volatility

Using historical cost reduces the volatility of reported earnings and equity. Fair value accounting, which requires assets and liabilities to be revalued to their current market values, can lead to significant fluctuations in financial statements due to market volatility. Historical cost provides a more stable and predictable picture of a company's financial performance over time.

7. Comparability

Historical cost enhances the comparability of financial statements across different companies and over different time periods. Because assets are recorded at their original purchase price, it is easier to compare the financial performance of companies that have acquired similar assets at different times. This comparability is essential for investors and analysts who use financial statements to evaluate and compare different investment opportunities.

Limitations of Historical Cost

Despite its advantages, historical cost accounting also has some limitations:

• Irrelevance: Historical cost may not reflect the current economic value of an asset. In periods of inflation or deflation, the historical cost of an asset may be significantly different from its current market value.

• Lack of Comparability: While historical cost enhances comparability in some respects, it can also hinder comparability when assets are acquired at different times and under different market conditions.

• Distorted Financial Ratios: Historical cost can distort financial ratios, such as return on assets (ROA), if the book value of assets does not reflect their current economic value.

B) Explain capitalization of salary with its advantages and disadvantages.         (7)

Salary capitalization, also known as labor capitalization, is an accounting method where a portion of an employee's salary and related expenses are recorded as an asset on the balance sheet instead of being expensed on the income statement in the period they are incurred. This practice is typically applied when an employee's work directly contributes to the creation of a long-term asset, such as software development, building construction, or research and development projects.

In essence, the rationale behind salary capitalization is that the employee's efforts are creating future economic benefits for the company. Therefore, it's more appropriate to allocate the cost of their labor to the asset being created rather than immediately expensing it.

Advantages of Salary Capitalization

Capitalizing salary can offer several potential advantages for companies:

• Improved Matching Principle: It aligns the expense of labor with the revenue generated by the asset created. This provides a more accurate representation of the company's profitability over the asset's useful life.

• Enhanced Financial Ratios: Capitalizing salary can improve key financial ratios, such as the return on assets (ROA) and the profit margin. This is because the expense is deferred, leading to higher reported profits in the short term.

• Tax Benefits: In some jurisdictions, capitalizing salary may result in tax benefits. The capitalized costs can be depreciated over the asset's useful life, providing a tax deduction over time.

• More Accurate Asset Valuation: It provides a more accurate representation of the true cost of an asset. This is particularly important for assets that are internally developed, as it captures the labor costs associated with their creation.

• Attractiveness to Investors: Showing a higher profit margin can make the company more attractive to investors.

Disadvantages of Salary Capitalization

Despite the potential benefits, salary capitalization also has several disadvantages:

• Increased Complexity: It adds complexity to the accounting process. Companies need to implement robust time tracking and cost allocation systems to ensure accurate capitalization.

• Subjectivity: Determining the portion of salary to be capitalized can be subjective, especially when employees work on multiple projects. This can lead to inconsistencies and potential manipulation.

• Potential for Overstatement of Assets: If not done carefully, salary capitalization can lead to an overstatement of assets on the balance sheet. This can mislead investors and creditors about the company's financial health.

• Reduced Current Profitability: While it improves long-term profitability, it reduces current profitability. This may be a concern for companies that are focused on short-term results.

• Compliance Costs: Implementing and maintaining a salary capitalization system can be costly, especially for small businesses.

• Risk of Write-Downs: If the asset being created does not generate the expected economic benefits, the capitalized costs may need to be written down, resulting in a significant loss.

OR

Q 3 P) Explain the replacement cost model with its advantages        (8) 

The replacement cost model is a valuation method that determines the value of an asset based on the current cost of replacing it with a new asset of similar functionality and utility. In simpler terms, it answers the question: "How much would it cost to replace this asset today?" This approach contrasts with historical cost accounting, which records assets at their original purchase price less accumulated depreciation.

The replacement cost model is particularly useful when dealing with assets that have experienced significant changes in value due to inflation, technological advancements, or market fluctuations. It provides a more up-to-date and relevant valuation compared to historical cost, which may not reflect the asset's true economic worth.

Advantages of the Replacement Cost Model

The replacement cost model offers several advantages over other valuation methods:

1. Reflects Current Market Conditions: Unlike historical cost accounting, the replacement cost model provides a valuation that is based on current market prices. This makes it more relevant and useful for decision-making, especially in times of inflation or rapid technological change.

2. Provides a Realistic Valuation: By focusing on the cost of replacing an asset with a new one, the replacement cost model provides a more realistic valuation of the asset's economic worth. This is particularly important for assets that have appreciated in value or have become more expensive to replace.

3. Facilitates Better Decision-Making: The replacement cost model provides decision-makers with more accurate information about the value of assets. This can lead to better decisions regarding investment, insurance coverage, and resource allocation.

4. Useful for Insurance Purposes: As mentioned earlier, the replacement cost model is widely used in the insurance industry to determine the amount of coverage needed to replace damaged or destroyed property. This ensures that policyholders receive adequate compensation to restore their assets to their original condition.

5. Compliance with Accounting Standards: Some accounting standards, such as IFRS, permit the use of the replacement cost model for valuing certain assets. This allows companies to comply with these standards and provide more transparent financial reporting.

6. Accounts for Technological Advancements: The replacement cost model takes into account technological advancements when determining the value of an asset. This ensures that the valuation reflects the cost of replacing the asset with a new one that incorporates the latest technological improvements.

Q) Opportunity cost has both advantages and disadvantages justify        (7)

Opportunity cost refers to the potential benefits lost when choosing one alternative over another. It plays a crucial role in decision-making by helping individuals and businesses assess the value of different options.

Advantages of Opportunity Cost

1. Better Decision-Making

   • Helps individuals and businesses evaluate the benefits and trade-offs of different choices.
   • Encourages strategic resource allocation for maximum returns.

2. Efficient Resource Utilization

   • Ensures that resources (time, money, labor) are used in the most productive way.
   • Prevents wastage by comparing alternatives before making a decision.

3. Supports Long-Term Planning

   • Helps businesses plan for sustainable growth by weighing future benefits.
   • Encourages investment in high-value opportunities rather than short-term gains.

4. Risk Assessment & Mitigation

   • Identifies potential losses associated with each choice, leading to more informed decisions.
   • Encourages businesses to consider alternative strategies to minimize risk.

Disadvantages of Opportunity Cost

1. Difficult to Quantify

   • Some opportunity costs, such as intangible benefits (e.g., employee satisfaction, brand reputation), are hard to measure accurately.
   • Not all costs can be expressed in monetary terms, making comparisons challenging.

2. Subjectivity in Decision-Making

   • Individuals and businesses may have different perspectives on what constitutes the "best" opportunity.
   • Biases or lack of complete information can lead to incorrect evaluations.

3. Short-Term Sacrifices for Long-Term Gains

   • Sometimes, choosing the best long-term option may require short-term sacrifices, such as reduced profits or higher costs initially.
   • This can be a challenge for businesses focused on immediate returns.

4. Overemphasis on Cost Avoidance

• Constantly evaluating opportunity costs may lead to hesitation in decision-making (analysis paralysis).
• Organizations may become overly risk-averse, missing out on innovative or growth-driven opportunities.

Q 4) A) What is human resource audit? Explain its features.    (8)

A Human Resource (HR) Audit is a systematic evaluation of an organization’s HR policies, practices, procedures, and compliance with labor laws. It assesses the efficiency and effectiveness of HR functions to identify strengths, weaknesses, and areas for improvement.

Features of HR Audit

1. Systematic & Objective Approach

   • Conducted in a structured manner to evaluate HR policies and procedures.
   • Uses qualitative and quantitative methods for an unbiased assessment.

2. Compliance-Focused

   • Ensures adherence to labor laws, company policies, and industry regulations.
   • Reduces legal risks and enhances corporate governance.

3. Comprehensive Evaluation

   • Covers all HR functions, including recruitment, training, payroll, performance management, and employee relations.

4. Performance-Oriented

   • Assesses the effectiveness of HR strategies in achieving business goals.
   • Identifies gaps in workforce planning and talent management.

5. Data-Driven & Analytical

   • Uses HR metrics, employee feedback, and documentation reviews for insights.
   • Supports decision-making with factual data and trend analysis.

6. Continuous Improvement Tool

   • Helps organizations enhance HR practices by identifying inefficiencies.
   • Provides recommendations for process optimization and strategic alignment.

7. Employee-Centric

• Evaluates workplace culture, employee satisfaction, and engagement levels.
• Helps in developing policies that improve the employee experience.

B) List and explain the benefits of HR audit.             (7)

An HR audit is a systematic review of an organization’s human resource policies, practices, and compliance. It helps improve HR effectiveness, legal compliance, and workforce management. Below are key benefits:

1. Ensures Legal Compliance

• Helps organizations adhere to labor laws, regulations, and company policies.
• Reduces the risk of legal penalties, lawsuits, and compliance violations.

2. Identifies Gaps & Areas for Improvement

• Highlights inefficiencies in recruitment, training, performance management, and employee relations.
• Provides recommendations for process improvement and HR best practices.

3. Enhances Employee Satisfaction & Engagement

• Identifies workplace issues affecting employee morale and productivity.
• Helps create policies that promote a positive work environment.

4. Improves HR Strategy Alignment

• Ensures HR policies align with business objectives and long-term organizational goals.
• Enhances workforce planning, talent management, and succession planning.

5. Boosts Operational Efficiency

• Evaluates HR processes to eliminate redundancies and optimize resources.
• Helps in streamlining payroll, benefits administration, and compliance tracking.

6. Strengthens Employer Branding

• Builds a reputation for fair, ethical, and employee-friendly HR practices.
• Enhances recruitment and retention of top talent.

7. Data-Driven Decision Making

• Uses HR metrics and analytics to make informed workforce-related decisions.
• Helps in budgeting, resource allocation, and performance assessment.

OR

Q4 P) Explain the interview method of conducting Hit audit along with its advantages. (8)

A hit audit is a crucial process for ensuring the integrity of web analytics data. It involves verifying that tracking codes are correctly implemented and that data is being accurately collected and reported. While automated tools and data analysis can identify discrepancies, the interview method offers a unique perspective by gathering information directly from the individuals involved in the implementation and maintenance of the tracking system.

The interview method involves conducting structured or semi-structured conversations with key stakeholders, such as developers, analysts, marketers, and product managers. These interviews aim to understand the tracking implementation process, identify potential issues, and gather context that may not be apparent from the data alone.

Conducting Hit Audit Interviews: A Step-by-Step Guide

The following steps outline the process of conducting hit audit interviews:

1. Identify Key Stakeholders:

• Begin by identifying the individuals who are most knowledgeable about the website or application's tracking implementation. This may include:

  • Web developers responsible for implementing tracking code.

  • Analytics specialists who configure and maintain tracking tools.

  • Marketing managers who define tracking requirements.

  • Product managers who oversee the user experience and data needs.

2. Develop Interview Questions:

• Create a set of questions tailored to each stakeholder's role and responsibilities. The questions should cover the following areas:

  • Tracking Implementation: How was the tracking code implemented? What tools and technologies were used? Are there any known issues or limitations?

  • Data Collection: What data is being collected? How is it being processed and stored? Are there any data quality concerns?

  • Reporting and Analysis: How is the data being used for reporting and analysis? Are there any discrepancies between the data and expected results?

  • Change Management: How are changes to the tracking implementation managed? What processes are in place to ensure data integrity?

  • Documentation: Is there documentation of the tracking implementation? Is it up-to-date and accurate?

Example Interview Questions:

• For Developers:

  • "Can you describe the process you followed to implement the tracking code?"

  • "What challenges did you encounter during the implementation?"

  • "How do you ensure that the tracking code is firing correctly on all pages?"

• For Analytics Specialists:

  • "How do you validate the accuracy of the data being collected?"

  • "What reports are you using to monitor the performance of the website or application?"

  • "Have you noticed any discrepancies in the data?"

• For Marketing Managers:

  • "What are your key performance indicators (KPIs) for the website or application?"

  • "How do you use the data to make marketing decisions?"

  • "Are you confident that the data is accurately reflecting user behavior?"

3. Schedule and Conduct Interviews:

• Schedule interviews with each stakeholder, allowing sufficient time for a thorough discussion.

• Conduct the interviews in a comfortable and non-threatening environment.

• Explain the purpose of the interview and assure stakeholders that their feedback will be used to improve the tracking implementation.

• Ask open-ended questions and encourage stakeholders to provide detailed answers.

• Listen carefully and take notes on key points and concerns.

4. Analyze Interview Data:

• After conducting the interviews, analyze the data to identify common themes, discrepancies, and potential issues.

• Compare the interview findings with the data analysis results to gain a more complete understanding of the tracking implementation.

• Document the findings and recommendations in a clear and concise report.

5. Develop and Implement Recommendations:

• Based on the interview findings and data analysis, develop recommendations for improving the tracking implementation.

• Prioritize the recommendations based on their impact and feasibility.

• Work with the stakeholders to implement the recommendations and ensure that the changes are properly tested and validated.

Advantages of the Interview Method

The interview method offers several advantages over relying solely on automated tools and data analysis:

• Provides Contextual Understanding: Interviews provide valuable context that may not be apparent from the data alone. Stakeholders can explain the rationale behind certain implementation decisions, identify potential issues, and provide insights into user behavior.

• Identifies Hidden Issues: Interviews can uncover hidden issues that may not be detectable through automated tools. For example, a developer may be aware of a bug in the tracking code that is not yet reflected in the data.

• Improves Communication and Collaboration: The interview process can improve communication and collaboration between different teams involved in the tracking implementation. It provides an opportunity for stakeholders to share their perspectives and work together to resolve issues.

• Enhances Data Quality: By identifying and addressing issues with the tracking implementation, the interview method can enhance the quality of the data being collected. This leads to more accurate reporting and analysis, which in turn supports better decision-making.

• Facilitates Knowledge Transfer: Interviews can facilitate knowledge transfer between stakeholders, ensuring that everyone is aware of the tracking implementation and its limitations. This can help to prevent future issues and improve the overall efficiency of the tracking process.

• Uncovers Business Requirements: Interviews with marketing and product teams can uncover the business requirements that drive the tracking implementation. This ensures that the data being collected is aligned with the organization's goals and objectives.

Q) Explain any three issues that may arise in case of HR audits

1. Non-Compliance with Labor Laws

One of the most critical issues that can be uncovered during an HR audit is non-compliance with labor laws. Labor laws are designed to protect employees' rights and ensure fair treatment in the workplace. Failure to comply with these laws can result in significant legal and financial repercussions for the organization, including fines, lawsuits, and damage to its reputation.

Examples of Non-Compliance:

• Wage and Hour Violations: This includes issues such as failing to pay minimum wage, misclassifying employees as exempt from overtime pay, not providing required meal and rest breaks, and inaccurate record-keeping of hours worked. For instance, an audit might reveal that employees classified as "salaried" are actually performing non-exempt duties and are therefore entitled to overtime pay.

• Discrimination and Harassment: HR audits can uncover instances of discrimination based on protected characteristics such as race, gender, religion, age, disability, or sexual orientation. This can manifest in hiring practices, promotions, compensation, or termination decisions. Similarly, audits can reveal a hostile work environment due to harassment, which the organization has failed to address adequately.

• Immigration Compliance: Organizations must comply with immigration laws when hiring foreign workers. An audit might reveal that the organization has not properly verified the work authorization of its employees or has failed to comply with the requirements of visa programs.

• Safety Violations: Workplace safety is governed by laws like OSHA (Occupational Safety and Health Administration). An HR audit can reveal failures in safety training, inadequate safety equipment, or a lack of procedures for reporting and addressing workplace hazards.

• Leave Laws: Non-compliance can also occur with laws like the Family and Medical Leave Act (FMLA) or state-specific leave laws. This could involve denying eligible employees leave, failing to properly track leave time, or retaliating against employees who take leave.

2. Inadequate Documentation

Another significant issue that can be identified during an HR audit is inadequate documentation. Proper documentation is essential for demonstrating compliance with laws and regulations, supporting HR decisions, and protecting the organization in the event of legal challenges. A lack of adequate documentation can create significant risks and liabilities.

Examples of Inadequate Documentation:

• Missing or Incomplete Employee Files: Employee files should contain essential documents such as employment applications, resumes, offer letters, performance evaluations, disciplinary actions, and termination paperwork. Missing or incomplete files can make it difficult to defend against claims of discrimination or wrongful termination.

• Lack of Written Policies and Procedures: Organizations should have written policies and procedures covering key HR areas such as hiring, compensation, performance management, and termination. A lack of written policies can lead to inconsistent application of HR practices and increase the risk of legal challenges.

• Poorly Documented Performance Management: Performance evaluations should be documented thoroughly and objectively, providing specific examples of employee performance and areas for improvement. Poorly documented performance evaluations can be difficult to defend if an employee challenges a performance-related decision.

• Insufficient Records of Training: Organizations should maintain records of employee training, including the topics covered, the dates of training, and the names of attendees. This is particularly important for safety training and compliance training.

• Absence of Documentation for Disciplinary Actions: Any disciplinary actions taken against employees should be documented in detail, including the reasons for the action, the steps taken to address the issue, and the employee's response. A lack of documentation can make it difficult to justify disciplinary actions if they are challenged.

3. Inconsistent Application of HR Policies

Inconsistent application of HR policies can lead to perceptions of unfairness, discrimination, and favoritism among employees. This can damage employee morale, increase turnover, and create a breeding ground for legal challenges. An HR audit can reveal inconsistencies in how policies are applied across different departments, locations, or employee groups.

Examples of Inconsistent Application:

• Disparate Treatment in Disciplinary Actions: Applying disciplinary policies differently to employees who commit similar offenses can lead to claims of discrimination. For example, if one employee is terminated for tardiness while another employee with a similar record receives only a warning, this could be seen as inconsistent application.

• Unequal Enforcement of Performance Standards: Holding some employees to higher performance standards than others, without a legitimate business reason, can create perceptions of unfairness. This can be particularly problematic if the higher standards are applied to employees from a protected group.

• Inconsistent Application of Leave Policies: Granting leave requests to some employees while denying similar requests from others, without a clear and consistent rationale, can lead to dissatisfaction and potential legal challenges.

• Variations in Compensation Practices: Significant variations in compensation for employees performing similar work, without justifiable reasons such as experience or performance, can raise concerns about pay equity.

• Selective Enforcement of Workplace Rules: Enforcing workplace rules selectively, such as dress code or attendance policies, can create a perception that some employees are being treated more favorably than others.

Q.5 Explain the monetary and non-monetary method valuation of HR in brief. (15)

Monetary Valuation Methods

Monetary valuation methods attempt to quantify the value of human resources in financial terms. These methods aim to translate the contributions of employees into measurable monetary figures, allowing for a direct comparison with other assets and investments.

1. Historical Cost Method

• This is the simplest method, which involves capitalizing the actual costs of recruiting, hiring, training, and developing employees. These costs are then amortized over the expected useful life of the employee within the organization.

• Advantages: Easy to implement and understand, as it relies on readily available data.

• Disadvantages: Fails to account for the future value or potential of employees. It treats employees as depreciating assets rather than appreciating ones. It also ignores factors like employee performance and market value.

2. Replacement Cost Method

• This method estimates the cost of replacing an existing employee with someone of similar skills and experience. It includes costs associated with recruitment, selection, training, and lost productivity during the replacement period.

• Advantages: Provides a more realistic assessment of the cost of losing an employee than the historical cost method.

• Disadvantages: Can be difficult to accurately estimate all replacement costs, especially for specialized or high-level positions. It also doesn't account for the potential for improvement or the unique contributions of the existing employee.

3. Opportunity Cost Method

• This method focuses on the potential profit that could be generated by an employee if they were deployed in their best alternative use within the organization. It considers the value of the employee's skills and experience in different roles and assigns a value based on the highest potential return.

• Advantages: Highlights the strategic importance of employee placement and resource allocation.

• Disadvantages: Difficult to accurately assess the potential profit in different roles, as it requires subjective judgment and forecasting.

4. Economic Value Added (EVA) Method

• This method measures the economic profit generated by employees after deducting the cost of capital. It assesses the extent to which employees contribute to the organization's overall profitability.

• Advantages: Provides a direct link between employee performance and financial results.

• Disadvantages: Can be challenging to attribute specific financial results to individual employees or teams. It also requires sophisticated financial analysis.

5. Human Resource Accounting (HRA)

• This is a comprehensive approach that incorporates various monetary valuation methods to provide a holistic view of the value of human resources. It involves tracking and reporting the costs and contributions of employees as assets on the organization's balance sheet.

• Advantages: Provides a more complete and accurate picture of the value of human resources than any single method.

• Disadvantages: Complex and time-consuming to implement, requiring significant investment in data collection and analysis.

Non-Monetary Valuation Methods

Non-monetary valuation methods focus on qualitative aspects of human resources that are difficult to quantify in financial terms. These methods recognize the importance of employee attitudes, skills, and contributions to the overall success of the organization.

1. Employee Satisfaction Surveys

• These surveys measure employee morale, engagement, and satisfaction with various aspects of their work environment, such as compensation, benefits, work-life balance, and opportunities for growth.

• Advantages: Provides valuable insights into employee attitudes and perceptions, which can impact productivity and retention.

• Disadvantages: Subjective and may be influenced by factors unrelated to the work environment. Requires careful design and administration to ensure accurate and reliable results.

2. Employee Engagement Metrics

• These metrics track employee involvement, commitment, and enthusiasm for their work. They may include measures of absenteeism, turnover, productivity, and customer satisfaction.

• Advantages: Provides a more objective measure of employee motivation and performance than satisfaction surveys.

• Disadvantages: Can be difficult to isolate the impact of employee engagement from other factors that influence performance.

3. Skills and Competency Inventories

• These inventories assess the skills, knowledge, and abilities of employees. They can be used to identify skill gaps, develop training programs, and make informed decisions about employee placement and promotion.

• Advantages: Provides a clear picture of the organization's human capital resources and their potential for future growth.

• Disadvantages: Can be time-consuming and expensive to develop and maintain. Requires ongoing updates to reflect changes in employee skills and organizational needs.

4. Performance Appraisals

• These appraisals evaluate employee performance against predetermined goals and objectives. They provide feedback on strengths and weaknesses and identify areas for improvement.

• Advantages: Provides a structured framework for evaluating employee performance and identifying high-potential employees.

• Disadvantages: Can be subjective and biased, depending on the rater's perceptions and biases. Requires careful training and calibration to ensure fairness and accuracy.

5. 360-Degree Feedback

• This method gathers feedback from multiple sources, including supervisors, peers, subordinates, and customers. It provides a more comprehensive and balanced view of employee performance than traditional performance appraisals.

• Advantages: Provides a more accurate and reliable assessment of employee performance by incorporating multiple perspectives.

• Disadvantages: Can be time-consuming and expensive to administer. Requires careful management to ensure confidentiality and prevent retaliation.

6. Organizational Culture Assessments

• These assessments evaluate the values, beliefs, and norms that shape the organization's culture. They can be used to identify cultural strengths and weaknesses and develop strategies to improve employee engagement and performance.

• Advantages: Provides valuable insights into the organization's culture and its impact on employee behavior and performance.

• Disadvantages: Can be difficult to accurately assess organizational culture, as it is often implicit and unwritten. Requires careful observation and analysis to identify key cultural elements.

OR

Q.5 Write short note on (any three)                            [15]

1. New Hire orientation process

New hire orientation is the formal process of introducing new employees to the organization, its policies, people, systems and work environment. It is usually conducted on the first day or during the initial weeks of employment. The goal is to help new workers feel comfortable, informed and ready to start their job confidently.

Objectives of New Hire Orientation

• Familiarize the employee with company rules, values and culture

• Explain job duties, performance standards and expectations

• Introduce coworkers, supervisors and the work environment

• Complete necessary joining formalities and documentation

• Build confidence and reduce anxiety for the new employee

• Help the new hire become productive faster

Steps in the New Hire Orientation Process

1. Pre-Arrival Preparation

Before the employee joins, the organization prepares by:

• Sending joining instructions

• Assigning a workstation or equipment

• Preparing ID cards, email access and necessary documents

• Informing concerned departments and team members

Effective preparation creates a smooth first-day experience.

2. Welcome and Introduction

On the first day, HR or the manager:

• Welcomes the new employee

• Introduces them to colleagues, team members and key staff

• Gives a tour of the workplace (departments, cafeteria, facilities etc.)

This step helps the employee feel included and comfortable.

3. Completion of Documentation

The new employee completes required legal and HR paperwork such as:

• Employment forms

• Bank details for salary

• Identity proofs

• Policy agreements (for example confidentiality or code of conduct)

HR verifies documents and updates employee records.

4. Company Overview

The new hire is briefed about:

• Company history and background

• Mission, vision and values

• Organizational structure

• Products and services

• Market position and competitors

This helps them understand the business they are joining.

5. HR Policy and Rules Orientation

The HR department explains:

• Working hours and shifts

• Leave policy

• Attendance rules

• Dress code (if any)

• Sexual harassment policy

• Health and safety rules

• Workplace behavior standards

Clear communication prevents misunderstandings later.

6. Job Role and Responsibilities

The immediate supervisor explains:

• Job duties and responsibilities

• Performance expectations

• Reporting structure

• Key performance indicators (KPIs)

• Work processes, tools and systems

This ensures role clarity from day one.

7. Introduction to IT Systems and Tools

The employee receives:

• Computer or workstation access

• Email setup

• Login credentials

• Introduction to software, communication tools and workflow systems

Training is provided if required.

8. Training and Development Plan

Some organizations include:

• Job training

• Shadowing senior employees

• On-the-job learning assignments

• Training schedule for the first few weeks

This speeds up the employee’s learning curve.

9. Interaction and Engagement

The new employee may participate in:

• Team meetings

• One-on-one discussions

• Buddy or mentor interactions

• Informal sessions or lunch with colleagues

Such engagement builds rapport and belonging.

10. Feedback and Follow-Up

After a few days or weeks, HR or the manager:

• Checks how the employee is adjusting

• Resolves issues or confusion

• Collects feedback on the orientation experience

This helps improve the orientation process in future.

Benefits of New Hire Orientation

To the employee:

• Reduces anxiety and confusion

• Builds confidence

• Helps understand job expectations

• Creates a sense of belonging

To the organization:

• Faster productivity

• Lower turnover

• Better employee engagement

• Stronger workplace culture

• Fewer mistakes due to unclear rules

2. Role of HR auditor

An HR auditor has the responsibility of reviewing, examining and evaluating the entire Human Resource system of an organization. The purpose is to determine how well HR policies, procedures and practices support organizational objectives and whether they comply with legal and professional standards. The audit is systematic, objective and aimed at improvement.

1. Evaluating HR Objectives and Policies

The HR auditor examines whether the organization has clear HR objectives and policies and whether they:

• Align with organizational goals

• Reflect current laws and industry standards

• Are properly documented and communicated

If the policies are outdated or unclear, the auditor identifies the need for revision.

2. Ensuring Legal and Policy Compliance

One of the primary roles of the HR auditor is to check whether HR practices follow:

• Labor laws

• Industrial relations legislation

• Equal opportunity laws

• Health and safety rules

• Government notifications

• Organizational rules

This protects the organization from fines, penalties, disputes and litigation.

3. Reviewing Operational Efficiency of HR Functions

The auditor assesses how efficiently the HR department is performing activities such as:

• Manpower planning

• Recruitment and selection

• Training and development

• Compensation and benefits

• Performance appraisal

• Employee welfare

• Disciplinary action

• Promotions and transfers

This shows how strong and effective the HR function is in daily operations.

4. Identifying Strengths and Weaknesses

Through detailed evaluation, the auditor:

• Highlights areas in which HR is performing well

• Points out inefficiencies, mistakes and gaps

• Detects risks that may affect productivity or compliance

This detailed diagnosis allows management to take corrective action.

5. Reviewing HR Records and Documentation

Proper documentation is necessary for legal and operational reasons. The HR auditor checks the completeness and accuracy of:

• Personnel files

• Job descriptions

• Appointment letters

• Attendance and leave records

• Payroll and benefits files

• Training records

• Grievance and disciplinary records

Poor documentation indicates weak HR controls.

6. Measuring HR Performance through Data

The auditor collects and analyzes HR data to understand the performance of HR systems. Some common metrics include:

• Turnover rate

• Absenteeism rate

• Recruitment cost per hire

• Training cost per employee

• Time taken to fill vacancies

• Appraisal results

• Productivity per employee

Data helps provide objective evaluation instead of guesswork.

7. Assessing Employee Satisfaction and Workplace Climate

The auditor often evaluates the employee experience by studying:

• Job satisfaction levels

• Motivation and engagement

• Morale and trust

• Work culture

• Communication systems

• Grievance handling processes

A satisfied workforce typically shows higher productivity and loyalty.

8. Benchmarking with Standards and Best Practices

The HR auditor may compare the organization’s systems with:

• Industry benchmarks

• External audit checklists

• Practices of leading companies

• Professional guidelines

This helps determine how advanced or outdated the HR system is compared to competition.

9. Suggesting Improvements and Action Plans

After reviewing findings, the auditor:

• Gives practical and realistic recommendations

• Suggests changes in policies and systems

• Helps streamline HR processes

• Recommends ways to reduce cost and increase efficiency

• Advises on improving employee welfare and development

The focus is always on continuous improvement.

10. Reporting Findings to Management

Finally, the HR auditor prepares a formal audit report. It includes:

• Observations

• Strengths and weaknesses

• Data and analysis

• Legal risks (if any)

• Recommended action steps

• Time frame for improvement

This report becomes an important tool for future HR planning and decision-making.

11. Assisting in Future HR Strategy

Based on the audit findings, the HR auditor helps management:

• Improve long-term HR plans

• Set new HR goals

• Align HR systems with business strategy

• Build a stronger people-focused organization

This ensures HR is not only administrative but also strategic in nature.

3. Human resource accounting

Human Resource Accounting (HRA) is the process of measuring and reporting the value of human capital in an organization. It aims to quantify the financial worth of employees’ skills, knowledge, and contributions to the company.

Human Resource Accounting is a system of measuring the cost and value of employees to an organization. Instead of treating staff expenses only as costs, HRA considers employees as assets whose skills, experience, knowledge and productivity increase organizational value.

It aims to record investments made in hiring, developing and retaining employees and also estimate the economic benefits generated from them.

Definition

• HRA is the process of identifying and reporting investments made in human resources that are not accounted for in traditional accounting systems.

• It measures the value of human capital and helps management make informed decisions about personnel.

Objectives of Human Resource Accounting

1. Provide information on the cost of human resources.

2. Improve the quality of decision-making related to recruitment, training and development.

3. Show the true earning capacity of the organization.

4. Help determine whether the organization is using its human resources effectively.

5. Assist in workforce planning, budgeting and HR performance evaluation.

6. Communicate the value of human assets to stakeholders.

Importance

• Encourages management to treat employees as valuable assets rather than expenses.

• Helps evaluate the return on investment in HR.

• Improves planning for training, staffing and development.

• Supports better employee-related decisions.

• May help reduce employee turnover if data shows loss due to attrition.

• Provides a more realistic and accurate picture of organizational worth.

Methods of Valuation in HRA

Different methods are used to calculate the value of human resources. Major approaches include:

1. Cost-Based Methods

These focus on estimating the cost spent on acquiring and developing employees.

a. Historical Cost Method

Records the actual cost spent on recruitment, selection, training and development of employees.

Advantages: Simple and easy to apply 

Limitation: Does not reflect current value or employee performance

b. Replacement Cost Method

Estimates how much it would cost to replace existing employees with new ones having similar skills and experience.

Advantages: More realistic than historical cost

Limitation: Difficult to calculate accurately

2. Value-Based Methods

These estimate how much value employees create for the company.

a. Present Value of Future Earnings Method

Calculates the net present value of the future earnings employees are expected to generate for the company during their service.

b. Lev and Schwartz Model

One of the most widely applied models. It estimates the value of human resources based on:

• Salary for each age group

• Number of employees

• Average retirement age

• Discount rate

3. Non-Monetary Methods

These methods assign no rupee value but measure qualities like:

• Skill levels

• Performance

• Employee satisfaction

• Productivity

• Potential

Examples:

• Skill inventory

• Ratings and performance scores

• Human resource scorecards

Advantages of HRA

• Helps management understand the impact of HR investments.

• Enhances workforce planning.

• Promotes transparency in reporting.

• Encourages long-term HR development programs.

• Shows how employee performance affects organizational profits.

Limitations of HRA

1. No universally accepted method of valuation.

2. Human value is subjective and difficult to measure accurately.

3. Employees may feel uncomfortable being assigned a monetary value.

4. Financial statements prepared under law do not recognize human assets officially.

5. Data collection and calculation can be complex.

4. Questionnaire method

The questionnaire method is a structured data collection tool used during an HR audit. In this method, the auditor prepares a set of written questions that are given to employees, managers or HR staff to gather information about the functioning of HR policies, procedures and workplace practices.

It helps collect feedback directly from the people who experience HR systems on a daily basis.

Purpose

The main objective of using a questionnaire in an HR audit is to:

• Understand how well HR policies are working in the organization

• Identify strengths and weaknesses in HR processes

• Measure employee perceptions and satisfaction

• Detect gaps between policy and actual practices

• Provide a factual basis for improving the HR system

Process

The questionnaire method usually follows several steps:

1. Planning

The HR auditor identifies the areas that need to be reviewed. This may include recruitment, job design, training, employee relations, performance management, legislation compliance and compensation.

2. Designing the questionnaire

Questions are prepared in a clear and simple format. Key qualities of a good questionnaire include:

• Easy to understand

• Relevant to the HR audit

• Neutral and unbiased

• Structured in a logical order

Questionnaires normally consist of:

• Close-ended questions for quick and objective answers

• Open-ended questions for detailed feedback

3. Selecting respondents

The questionnaire may be distributed to:

• Employees at different levels

• Line managers and supervisors

• HR department staff

• Department heads

The choice depends on the area being audited.

4. Distribution

Questionnaires can be shared in different ways:

• Printed copies

• Email or digital forms

• Internal HR portals

Respondents are usually given a timeline to submit their answers.

5. Data collection

Completed questionnaires are collected and organized for analysis. Non-respondents may be reminded if needed.

6. Analysis

The auditor evaluates the responses to find patterns and trends. Common methods include:

• Statistical summaries

• Rating analysis

• Categorizing open-ended feedback

• Comparing responses across departments

7. Reporting

Finally, conclusions and recommendations are written in the HR audit report. The findings help management improve HR systems.

Types of Questions Used

1. Close-ended questions

These question formats provide fixed response options, such as:

• Yes or No

• Multiple choice

• Rating scales (for example 1 to 5)

Example:
“Rate the effectiveness of the training program:

1. Very poor

2. Poor

3. Average

4. Good

5. Excellent”

These help in quantitative analysis.

2. Open-ended questions

Respondents write answers in their own words. These provide deeper insights and explanations.

Example:
“What changes would you suggest to make the performance appraisal system more effective?”

Areas Covered in Questionnaire

A Questionnaire in HR audit may cover topics such as:

• Recruitment and selection

• Job descriptions

• Training and development

• Appraisal and promotion systems

• Compensation and benefits

• Disciplinary procedures

• Employee motivation

• Work environment

• Communication quality

• Legal and policy compliance

Advantages

1. Can reach many people quickly

It allows auditors to collect information from a large number of employees in a short time.

2. Low cost

Printed or digital questionnaires require fewer resources compared to interviews or focus groups.

3. Uniform information

Since all respondents answer the same questions, comparisons are easier and more accurate.

4. Encourages frank responses

Employees may express their views more openly, especially when anonymity is assured.

5. Saves time

Data can be analyzed quickly, especially when questions are structured.

Limitations

1. Limited depth

Responses may be short and lack explanation, especially in close-ended formats.

2. Misunderstanding of questions

If a question is unclear, the auditor cannot clarify it immediately.

3. Response rate may be low

Some employees may ignore the questionnaire or submit incomplete answers.

4. Cannot observe behavior

Unlike interviews or observation, this method only records what people say, not what they do.

5. Approaches of HR Audit

HR audits help organizations evaluate and improve their human resource policies, practices, and compliance. The key approaches to HR audit include:

1. Comparative Approach

In this method, the organization’s HR practices are compared with:

• A leading organization in the same industry, or

• A set of best-practice standards.

This helps identify gaps and improvement areas.

How it works:

• Select a benchmark company known for strong HR practices.

• Compare HR activities like recruitment, training, performance appraisal, compensation and employee relations.

• Identify areas where the current organization is ahead or behind.

Advantages:

• Highlights competitive standing.

• Offers practical improvement ideas.

Limitations:

• Benchmarking company data may not always be accessible.

• Practices that work in one organization may not always work the same in another.

2. Compliance Approach

This approach measures whether the organization follows:

• Employment laws and regulations

• Government policies

• Health and safety rules

• Internal rules and HR policies

How it works:

• Review HR manuals, policy documents, employee records and contracts.

• Check whether procedures comply with laws on wages, working hours, employee rights and social security.

• Identify compliance gaps and risks.

Why organizations use it:

• Helps avoid legal penalties.

• Reduces unsafe or unethical practices.

3. Statistical Approach

In this method, HR performance is evaluated using measurable data.

Examples of HR metrics:

• Employee turnover rate

• Absenteeism rate

• Training hours per employee

• Cost per hire

• Performance appraisal scores

• Productivity per employee

How it works:

• Collect HR data for different periods.

• Analyse trends to evaluate effectiveness and efficiency.

• Detect problem areas based on changes in numbers.

Advantages:

• Objective and data-driven.

• Helps track improvements over time.

4. Outside Authority Approach

In this approach, the organization uses standards developed by an external agency such as:

• HR consulting firms

• Professional associations

• Government bodies

• Industry standard setters

These external standards act as the reference for evaluation.

Why this approach is useful:

• Helps bring objectivity.

• Provides professional and recognized guidelines.

• Useful when internal expertise is limited.

Drawback:

• Standards may not fully match internal culture or needs.

5. Management by Objectives (MBO) Approach

The audit checks how well HR achieved goals that were set earlier.

• HR sets targets at the beginning of the year.
  Examples:

  • Reduce turnover by 10 percent.

  • Improve training effectiveness.

  • Fill vacancies within a defined time frame.

• At the end of the period, results are evaluated based on performance against these targets.

Features:

• Focuses on results and outcomes.

• Encourages accountability.

• Helps identify areas where HR needs to improve performance.

Elective: Operation Research (CBCGS)
Year	Month	Q.P.	Link
IMP Q.			Solution
Obj. Q			Solution
2019	April	Download	Solution
2019	November	Download	Solution
2022	November	Download	Solution
2023	April	Download	Solution
2023	November	Download	Solution
2024	April	Download	Solution
2024	November		Solution
2025	April

Elective: International Finance (CBCGS)
Year	Month	Q.P.	Link
IMP Q.			Solution
Obj. Q			Solution
2019	April	Download	Solution
2019	November	Download	Solution
2022	November	Download	Solution
2023	April	Download	Solution
2024	April	Download	Solution
2024	November	Download	Solution
2025	April

Elective: Brand Management (CBCGS)
Year	Month	Q.P.	Link
IMP Q.			Solution
Obj. Q			Solution
2019	April	Download	Solution
2019	November	Download	Solution
2023	April	Download	Solution
2024	April	Download	Solution
2024	November	Download	Solution
2025	April		Solution

Elective: HRM in Global Perspective (CBCGS)
Year	Month	Q.P.	Link
IMP Q.			Solution
Obj. Q			Solution
2019	April	Download	Solution
2019	November	Download	Solution
2023	April	Download	Solution
2024	April	Download	Solution
2024	November	Download	Solution
2025	April

Elective: Innovation Financial Service (CBCGS)
Year	Month	Q.P.	Link
IMP Q.			Solution
Obj. Q			Solution
2019	April	Download	Solution
2019	November	Download	Solution
2023	April	Download	Solution
2024	April	Download	Solution
2024	November	Download	Solution
2025	April		Solution

Elective: Retail Management (CBCGS)
Year	Month	Q.P.	Link
IMP Q.			Solution
Obj. Q			Solution
2019	April	Download	Solution
2019	November	Download	Solution
2023	April	Download	Solution
2024	April	Download	Solution
2024	November	Download
2025	April

Elective: Organizational Development (CBCGS)
Year	Month	Q.P.	Link
IMP Q.			Solution
Obj. Q			Solution
2019	April	Download	Solution
2019	November	Download	Solution
2023	April	Download	Solution
2024	April	Download	Solution
2024	November	Download	Solution
2025	April

Elective: Project Management (CBCGS)
Year	Month	Q.P.	Link
IMP Q.			Solution
Obj. Q			Solution
2019	April	Download	Solution
2019	November	Download	Solution
2023	April	Download	Solution
2024	April	Download	Solution
2024	November	Download	Solution
2025	April

Elective: International Marketing (CBCGS)
Year	Month	Q.P.	Link
IMP Q.			Solution
Obj. Q			Solution
2019	April	Download	Solution
2019	November	Download	Solution
2023	April	Download	Solution
2024	April	Download	Solution
2024	November	Download
2025	April

Elective: HRM in Service Sector Management (CBCGS)
Year	Month	Q.P.	Link
IMP Q.			Solution
Obj. Q			Solution
2019	April	Download	Solution
2019	November	Download	Solution
2023	April	Download	Solution
2024	April	Download	Solution
2024	November	Download
2025	April

Elective: Strategic Financial Management (CBCGS)
Year	Month	Q.P.	Link
IMP Q.			Solution
Obj. Q			Solution
2019	April	Download	Solution
2019	November	Download	Solution
2023	April	Download	Solution
2024	April	Download	Solution
2024	November	Download	Solution
2025	April

Elective: Media Planning (CBCGS)
Year	Month	Q.P.	Link
IMP Q.			Solution
Obj. Q			Solution
2019	April	Download	Solution
2019	November	Download	Solution
2023	April	Download	Solution
2024	April	Download	Solution
2024	November	Download	Solution
2025	April

Elective: Workforce Diversity (CBCGS)
Year	Month	Q.P.	Link
IMP Q.			Solution
Obj. Q			Solution
2023	April	Download	Solution
2024	April	Download	Solution
2024	November	Download
2025	April

Elective: Financing Rural Development (CBCGS)
Year	Month	Q.P.	Link
IMP Q.			Solution
Obj. Q			Solution
2023	April	Download	Solution
2024	April	Download	Solution
2024	November	Download
2025	April

Elective: Sport Marketing (CBCGS)
Year	Month	Q.P.	Link
IMP Q.			Solution
Obj. Q			Solution
2023	April	Download	Solution
2024	April	Download	Solution
2024	November	Download
2025	April

Elective: HRM Accounting & Audit (CBCGS)
Year	Month	Q.P.	Link
IMP Q.			Solution
Obj. Q			Solution
2019	April	Download	Solution
2019	November	Download	Solution
2023	April	Download	Solution
2024	April	Download	Solution
2024	November	Download	Solution
2025	April

Elective: Indirect Tax (CBCGS)
Year	Month	Q.P.	Link
IMP Q.			Solution
Obj. Q			Solution
2019	April	Download	Solution
2019	November	Download	Solution
2023	April	Download	Solution
2024	April	Download	Solution
2024	November	Download	Solution
2025	April

Elective: Marketing of Non-Profit Organization (CBCGS)
Year	Month	Q.P.	Link
IMP Q.			Solution
Obj. Q			Solution
2019	April	Download	Solution
2019	November	Download	Solution
2023	April	Download	Solution
2024	April	Download	Solution
2024	November	Download	Solution
2025	April

Elective: Indian Ethos in Management (CBCGS)
Year	Month	Q.P.	Link
IMP Q.			Solution
Obj. Q			Solution
2019	April	Download	Solution
2019	November	Download	Solution
2023	April	Download	Solution
2024	April	Download	Solution
2024	November	Download	Solution
2025	April